Fox Laments 'Stalled' Relations Between U.S., Mexico
Leader Says His Credibility Is Being Undermined by Bush's Failure
to Speed Immigration Reform
By Kevin Sullivan and Mary Jordan
In a speech in New York to the Council of the Americas, a U.S. business
organization concerned with hemispheric issues, Fox
said he and President Bush have set a positive new tone in relations.
But he argued that by now, 18 months after he took office,
Washington should have adopted some fundamental changes in its immigration
policies, including an increased number of
permanent visas for Mexicans and legal status for at least some of
the 3 million to 4 million undocumented Mexicans living in the
United States.
"Our progress in turning this conceptual breakthrough into concrete
agreements and policies appears to be stalled," he said,
according to Mexican officials who attended the private speech. "In
spite of our ongoing dialogue and our shared vision of the
future, there are still few tangible results."
"There can be no privileged U.S.-Mexico relationship without actual
progress on substantive issues," Fox said. "And there will
be no substantive progress without comprehensively addressing the issue
of migration."
Immigration is the single most important issue to Mexico, which shares
a 2,000-mile border with the United States. More than
23 million Mexicans and Mexican Americans live in the United States,
and last year they sent home about $9.3 billion in
remittances.
More than a year ago, Fox and Bush agreed to the highest-level review
ever of immigration policy, issuing a joint statement
saying that they hoped to create a new framework to make immigration
safer and more orderly. At least 325 Mexicans died
trying to sneak into the United States over deserts and mountains last
year.
Fox wants preferential visa status so more Mexicans can enter the United
States legally each year. He also wants more
guest-worker programs to allow Mexicans to legally find temporary work
in the United States. Most of all, he wants
Washington to grant legal status to at least some of the millions of
undocumented Mexicans who live and work in the United
States, many of whom have paid U.S. taxes for years.
Bush promised to consider those requests. But progress on bilateral
talks slowed because the two leaders' enthusiasm wasn't
shared by some members of Congress, who have said the United States
should be limiting rather than expanding immigration.
After the Sept. 11 terror attacks, the issue was pushed into the background
in Washington.
Mexicans believe that Fox's leverage with Bush is that it is in the
U.S. interest to have a strong ally on its southern border. Fox
has been one of Bush's closest allies, but now he is finding that an
alliance that is based on words and not action is a political
liability at home.
"This lack of progress makes it increasingly difficult to maintain political
and public support for what is perceived in Mexico as a
shift in our traditional foreign policy, formerly based on the need
to keep the U.S. at arm's length," Fox said tonight.
Fox has staked much of his presidency on improving relations with the
United States. But his popularity has plummeted as the
Bush administration has not produced new immigration policy. Critics,
especially in the Mexican Congress, call Fox a lackey
who brings home nothing but nice photos with Bush on Fox's visits to
the United States.
"All Fox gets is kisses," said Jorge Montaño, a former Mexican
ambassador to the United States. "We have gotten not even a
taco."
The Mexican Senate embarrassed Fox last month by using, for the first
time, its constitutional power to deny presidential
foreign travel to keep him from making a planned trip to the United
States. Mexican cartoonists portrayed Fox as a grounded
teenager; "Tonight Show" host Jay Leno called Fox the only Mexican
who could not get into the United States.
In another sign of his sensitivity to the rising criticism, Fox recently
canceled his scheduled May 19 commencement address at
the University of Notre Dame in Indiana, citing "political circumstances"
at home.
Fox also said tonight that the lack of progress on the Mexican agenda
in Washington was hurting his credibility and authority in
Latin America, preventing Mexico from taking a more powerful role in
crises in Colombia, Venezuela and Argentina.
He said leaders in the region interpret Washington's lack of progress
with Mexico as an indication of a general reluctance to
engage more closely in Latin America.
A top government official here, speaking on the condition of anonymity,
said Fox decided to air his frustration tonight in a
private speech because he is reluctant to offend a president he considers
an ally and close friend.
Bush "is Mexico's best friend," the official said. "We don't want to throw mud in the face of the administration."
But, he said, "if we wait any longer, we could end up with a complete
stalemate in the relationship," the official said. "All the
momentum we've achieved in the past year could be lost."
Rafael Fernandez de Castro, a leading international relations professor
here, said Fox needs to press harder without sounding
fed up, "because that could put Mexico-U.S. relations in the ice chest."
Fox tonight told the U.S. business group, founded by retired Chase Manhattan
Bank chief executive David Rockefeller, that
Mexico has kept its end of the bargain: Mexico has tightened border
security and financial regulations to make it harder for
terrorists to move money. Mexico has also arrested several drug lords
long sought by the United States.
In response, many in Mexico believe they have actually lost ground on
immigration. They cite, for example, a recent Supreme
Court decision that employers do not have the same responsibilities
to undocumented migrant workers as they do to U.S.
citizens.
"Fox hasn't lifted his voice," said Carolina Viggiano Austria, a legislator
from the opposition Institutional Revolutionary Party.
"He hasn't won anything with his complacent attitude."