Advisor warned White House attack possible
By CAROL ROSENBERG
Herald Staff Writer
President Clinton's Cuba advisor was so worried about a confrontation between
Havana and Brothers to the Rescue on Feb. 23, 1996, that he wrote an e-mail
to
the White House national security deputy that evening warning of a possible
shootdown.
The next day, Feb. 24, 1996, Cuban MiGs shot down two Brothers planes,
killing
four men.
Richard Nuccio told The Herald Saturday night that he never got a reply
to the
memo he sent at 6:44 p.m. Feb. 23, using the White House electronic mail
system,
to Sandy Berger, who today is Clinton's national security advisor.
He also tried several times to speak to Berger by telephone, before and
after he
sent the note. But, he said, he has since concluded that ``the crisis du
jour was
taking priority over my phone calls.''
At the time, Berger was the No. 2 person at the White House National Security
Council, the deputy to advisor Anthony Lake. Nuccio was special advisor
on
Cuba to both Clinton and the secretary of state.
Memo was read later
White House spokesman P.J. Crowley said late Saturday that Berger did receive
Nuccio's memo ``but he did not have a chance to read it that evening.''
He added: ``Rick was acting on his intuition. In point of fact, we had
no
intelligence to suggest that the Cubans would act in a hostile manner.''
Nuccio said Saturday from his home in the Washington suburbs that he included
the shootdown scenario to get Berger's attention.
He said that he did not believe a shootdown was imminent and that he considered
it unimaginable unless the Brothers overflew Cuba. He was worried, Nuccio
said,
because he had unsuccessfully tried to get the Federal Aviation Administration
to
stop Brothers founder Jose Basulto from flying.
``But because of the kind of laws we have in this country we live in, we
couldn't
stop his provocations and aggressive behavior,'' he said.
Nuccio left the administration in February 1997. He first disclosed the
existence of
the memo to El Nuevo Herald staff writer Peter Katel.
`Tensions sufficiently high'
Expanding on the disclosure Saturday night, Nuccio read The Herald his
archive
copy. It included the following:
``Reports by Miami police have raised suspicions that a Cuban-American
group,
Brothers to the Rescue, may be planning another in a series of violations
of Cuban
air space tomorrow. Previous overflights by Jose Basulto . . . have been
met with
restraint by Cuban authorities. Tensions are sufficiently high within Cuba,
however,
that we feel this may finally tip the Cubans toward an attempt to shoot
down or
force down the planes.
``We only know for sure that Basulto . . . has filed a flight plan for
the Bahamas.
He has done this before and diverted to drop leaflets over Havana. . .
.
``We have repeatedly tried to get FAA to act on the previous overflights
without
success. Informed of the possible overflight, Miami authorities have only
agreed to
issue another warning to him, if they encounter him.
``By our laws there may not be much more we can do.''
Elaborating, Nuccio said he had conflicting sentiments when he wrote the
memo.
``No one thought the first thing that the Cubans would do would be to shoot
them
down,'' he said. ``But they were practicing confronting slow-flying aircraft
in the
couple of months before the shootdown.''
Tampa attorney Ralph Fernandez has claimed for more than a year that a
Cuban
commercial pilot -- Adel Regalado Ulloa, who defected to the United States
several months after the shootdown -- had his aircraft used in a dry run
of the
Brothers attack.
`Castro given opportunity'
Upon learning of the Nuccio memo, Basulto said its disclosure bolstered
his
argument that ``somebody [high up in the Clinton administration] must have
put
their hands in there and made it possible'' for his planes to be shot down.
``The State Department never sent a note to Cuba saying, `Don't you dare
shoot
down those airplanes over international waters,' '' said Basulto. ``I was
sentenced
to death by the U.S. government and Castro was given the opportunity to
execute
me.''
Basulto and his Cessna escaped the MiGs, but Carlos Costa, Pablo Morales,
Mario de la Peña and Armando Alejandre were killed in two other
planes.
Nuccio said that, on the eve of the shootdown, he and State Department
officials
didn't know that the FAA routinely passed along the Brothers' flight plans
to
Havana traffic control. So, although he considered delivering a stern warning
to the
Cubans on Feb. 23 -- after a performance of the Cuban ballet at Washington's
Kennedy Center -- he consulted with Joseph Sullivan, chief of the U.S.
Interests
Section in Havana, and decided against it.
``We thought, naively, as it turns out, that we would be calling the Cubans'
attention to something they might not be focused on otherwise.''
Added Crowley, the White House's National Security Council spokesman: ``The
responsibility lies with the Cubans in shooting down unarmed civilian aircraft
in an
action that amounts to cold-blooded murder. . . . My understanding is we
had no
information to suggest that the Cubans planned to shoot these aircraft
down.''