By PETER WATROUS
HAVANA -- It
was in the air: the thrill of the illicit and the new, the
excitement of
discovery and the charge of an encounter with idols.
And it didn't
take place on a baseball field.
Just after the
Baltimore Orioles broke ground by playing a Cuban team
here, musicians
by the score and fans by the thousands poured into the
Karl Marx Theater
on Sunday night in this city's elegant Playa district for
the Music Bridges
concert, the biggest convergence of foreign and
Cuban musicians
since the revolution. Before that came a week of
impromptu collaborations
outdoors and in makeshift studios.
From the United
States came singers like Bonnie Raitt, Jimmy Buffett,
Beth Nielsen
Chapman, Joan Osborne, Lisa Loeb, Burt Bacharach and
more. The Cubans
brought together musicians from the folk, rock and
popular dance
music scenes.
In the end the
all-star concert at the Karl Marx flickered and droned, the
lead-up concerts
had people dancing and cheering, and the future of this
enterprise,
musical or otherwise, seemed as hazy and unpredictable as
anything else
involving Cuban-American relations.
Music Bridges,
an organization that specializes in concerts in politically
sensitive countries,
had spent a year and a half pulling together the legal
and practical
permission from the United States and Cuba.
Music Bridges,
with its 40-some participating American musicians, had
come to Havana
and taken more than 120 rooms in the Hotel Nacional,
overlooking
the ocean.
The organization
filled the sixth-floor executive offices and the
presidential
suite, along with three rooms that had been converted into
recording studios.
For a week Cuban and American musicians were to
collaborate
on songs and to present the works on the final night in a long
concert at the
Karl Marx Theater.
At events around
the city American musicians were getting a feel for the
power of Cuban
music and its bacchanalian spirit. In the wee hours of
Thursday night
at La Cecilia nightclub, Michael Franti, a rapper and band
leader from
San Francisco, mounted the stage with Cuba's version of the
Rolling Stones,
Los Van Van, a 30-year-old institution playing
hard-rocking
dance music.
Franti started
rapping and repeating a phrase, and Pedrito, one of the
group's singers,
entered the fray; the two swapped nonsense syllables,
but with rhythm.
It would have brought down the roof, but La Cecilia is
outdoors. Members
of the audience -- made up of faranduleros, the
habitues of
Havana's night life scene, Music Bridges staff members and
performers,
and journalists -- were impressed and they danced.
On Saturday at
the Charlie Chaplin Theater in the Vedado district,
Americans and
what remains of members of Cuba's intellectual culture
had the chance
to hear the Buena Vista Social Club play cha-cha-chas,
mambos and boleros
that have mostly fallen into disregard.
The performance,
which was not part of Music Bridges, offered an
opportunity
to hear music with extreme grace and humor, one of the
great musical
syntheses of the New World, where classical, jazz and
African music
merged into something special. Played by old, weary and
worn musicians,
the music reflected the prerevolution grandeur of Cuban
society, as
does the best architecture of the city, also worn, weary and
prerevolutionary.
The American
producer of the Buena Vista band, Ry Cooder, who was
in Cuba for
a screening of a new documentary about the group directed
by Wim Wenders,
said of the music: "I've never seen any scene explode
as quickly as
this. That's good, and that's bad."
Regardless, it
was one of the greatest windfalls of positive publicity the
Cuban government
has had in its post-Batista history. Though the
economic embargo
of Cuba, the Helms-Burton Act, leaves a loophole
for cultural
exchange, nothing of this size had been attempted before.
The Cuban side,
which has everything to gain from such exchanges,
regularly proclaimed
its happiness with events like this one; the American
side was not
so sure.
Though many of
the American musicians had barely a clue about either
Cuban music
or Cuban-American relations, the predominant view
seemed to be
that antagonistic relationships between the two countries
did little for
Cubans or Americans. Ms. Raitt, who came fully informed
and loaded for
bear, brought 37 guitars to give away, and a pile of
medicine.
"Everybody knows
that the embargo the American government has
placed on Cuba
just hurts the Cuban people," Ms. Raitt said. "So I went
to my guitar
company and bought a bunch of guitars at cost, and I'm
going to give
lots away to the music school here, and the rest to people I
know."
In the last year
Cuba has cracked down on the casual prostitution
prevalent on
the streets and in the dance clubs. Where clubs with live
music were once
almost too numerous to count, now nearly all have been
closed by the
government. One result is that the best bands no longer
play regularly,
and one of the world's great music scenes is moribund.
Instead, Havana
seems to be undergoing renovation for tourists, and Old
Havana is flooded
with new hotels and stores that suggest that the
economy is doing
well. Unfortunately the average Cuban is not allowed
to enter the
hotels and has little or no access to the dollar economy that
has sprung up
alongside the peso.
In a seeming
effort to ensure that the city is safe for tourism and to reduce
crime, the police,
on nearly every corner, were stopping Cubans and
checking identification.
Some residents associated with the music
exchange said
that many Cubans from outside Havana were being
shipped to jail
or back home.
While generally
unaware of the politics, American visitors were stunned
by the skills
of their Cuban counterparts. Some musicians stayed at the
Nacional and
worked with their Cuban partners. Others, like N'Dea
Davenport, the
former lead singer from the British group the Brand New
Heavies, stayed
and worked in Old Havana with her writing partners.
"I love it here
regardless of the hardships," said Ms. Davenport, who
now lives in
New Orleans. "The reason I love New Orleans is that there's
music everywhere,
and it's the same here. Everybody sings or dances or
plays an instrument.
It's changing my life."
The average Cuban
musician, taught from age 7 in government-run
conservatories,
is among the best trained and musically literate in the
world, schooled
in classical music, pop and jazz. While the American
musicians were
discovering the riches of Cuban music, the Cubans were
learning plenty
from the Americans.
Like most of
their countrymen, Cuban musicians receive only bits and
pieces of information
from the outside world. They look to the United
States for musical
cues but get music from the most powerful stations in
Miami or New
Orleans, which guarantees a view of a music world heavy
on Kenny G and
the worst pop. Other information comes from furtive
conversations
or secondhand accounts of people who have seen bands in
Europe. And
maybe they will get the occasional recording.
"The most amazing
thing about this encounter is the ability to hang out
with our idols,
to learn what's behind the music that we've heard all our
lives," said
Luis de la Cruz, guitarist, composer and leader of the band
Bolsa Negra
(Black Market). "It's one thing to hear a bit of music on the
radio, but to
actually sit down with somebody we admire and ask
questions and
collaborate on something intimate like the writing process
is really incredible."
Carlos Varela,
one of Cuba's most important singer-songwriters,
collaborated
with the Indigo Girls. He has played in the United States a
few times and
has flirted with major record labels. But Cuba's isolation,
apart from the
infatuation with the island internationally, almost guarantees
the failure
of an international career. For him the weeklong stay was
important for
another reason.
"When I go to
the United States the next time, I have a hundred
telephone numbers
of musicians to call, new friends I've made," he said.
"People want
me to come to collaborate, to write and record with them.
For that reason
alone this is invaluable."
Chucho Valdes,
the dean of Cuban musicians, pianist and leader of the
group Irakere,
thought the encounter was going to leave a permanent
impression on
the Cuban music scene.
"I've never seen
anything like this," said Valdes, who is also the director
of the nearly
annual Havana Jazz Festival, which usually attracts a handful
of American
musicians. "The things that we lack, a formal sophistication
in pop music
and harmonic sense, we're learning right now. And the way
to produce sound,
to get a good sound."
Still, the final
Music Bridges concert was pretty much an artistic disaster,
unlike the weeklong
exchange. Generally American pop musicianship is,
to be kind,
basic. The Cubans were often reduced to being the
professional
hired hands backing the illiterate boss.
Most songs were
in English, with Americans leading the bands. The
Americans were
mostly white, mostly folk-oriented and mostly second
rate. It is
an old history. The recordings of the concert, and the music
made at the
Hotel National may be released, depending on legal
restrictions
imposed by the United States.
There were a
few good moments. Ms. Davenport tore the place apart
with a song
she and the Cuban singer Rene Banos sang called "Que
Importa," in
which they listed the differences between them, including
their beer-brand
preferences.
Ms. Osborne,
backed by Manolito y Su Trabuco, sang a deep and funny
blues that had
the audience on its feet. There were some mildly political
songs -- Ms.
Raitt sang "Cuba Is Way Too Cool" -- but most
performers stuck
to "We Are the Worldisms." (One tune was called
"One World.")
But most people,
though the musicians had worked hard on the songs,
weren't really
looking for an end. The means, in this case, was sufficient.
Copyright 1999 The New York Times Company