Bush weighs Helms-Burton law
Tom Carter
THE WASHINGTON TIMES
President Bush is facing his first major foreign
policy decision on U.S.-Cuba relations -- whether to waive or enforce a
U.S. law that allows American companies
to sue the island nation over land seized during its communist revolution.
President Clinton regularly exercised his
right to waive the provision under the terms of the 1996 Helms-Burton law,
sponsored by Sen. Jesse Helms and Rep.
Dan Burton.
Mr. Bush, who must make a decision by mid-July,
stands to anger the anti-Castro Cuban-American community in South Florida,
whose support helped put him in
the White House, if he continues to waive enforcement of the law.
But by allowing the law to be enforced, he
would exacerbate strained relations with the European Union, where companies
have invested heavily in Cuba.
At issue is a provision in the Helms-Burton
legislation, known as "Title 3." It allows U.S. "nationals" to use federal
courts to seek compensation from foreign
companies doing business in Cuba on property that was confiscated by
the island´s communist regime 40 years ago.
"President Bush is under a lot of pressure
to waive Title 3, but we are optimistic. His heart is in the right place,"
said Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Florida
Republican. "I am hoping, and wishing and praying that he allows these
guys whose property was stolen to go to court to get compensation."
Mrs. Ros-Lehtinen said that corporate lobbyists,
fearing a disruption of business relations with Europe, are working overtime
to persuade Mr. Bush to exercise
the waiver but that National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice is advising
that he allow the suits to go forward.
"If President Bush suspends [Title 3] there
will be great disillusionment in the Cuban-American community because they
wanted to think that this president was
different from Clinton," said Nicolas Gutierrez, a Miami lawyer.
Mr. Gutierrez represents families whose property
was confiscated and is now being used by foreign concerns that also do
business in the United States.
He said he has dozens of lawsuits ready to
be filed under Title 3 against companies such as Sol Melia, a Spanish hotel
concern; Labatt´s Brewing Co. in Canada;
the Venezuelan oil company that owns Citgo; and a host of other companies.
The European Union, some U.S. business interests,
left-leaning anti-embargo groups and the Cato Institute oppose the use
of U.S. courts for redress.
"Helms-Burton has antagonized our allies,
further isolated ordinary Cubans from the influence of American ideas and
strengthened the hand of the very
government the policy was supposed to undermine," said a recent Cato
Institute study. "The act has backfired."
Mr. Gutierrez said he spoke with Mr. Bush
at a Miami event recently and concluded that Mr. Bush is leaning toward
waiving the measure one more time.
If true, many Cuban-Americans want something
else: a murder indictment against Fidel Castro for the 1996 shootdown in
international airspace of two planes
operated by the Miami-based Cuban exile group, Brothers to the Rescue.
In Miami, a Cuban agent named Gerardo Hernandez
was found guilty on Friday of conspiracy to murder in the incident. Four
Americans died when the planes
were shot down by Cuban jet fighters.
"Our hope and expectation is that the president
will allow Title 3 to come into force. If that is not possible, at the
top of column B would be to get justice in the
case of the young men murdered in the Brothers to the Rescue shootdown,"
said Dennis Hays, Washington director of the Cuban American National Foundation.
Mr. Clinton signed the Cuban Liberty and Democratic
Solidarity Act, known as Helms-Burton for its Republican sponsors -- Mr.
Helms of North Carolina and
Mr. Burton of Indiana -- just days after the shootdown.
Shortly after Mr. Castro came to power in
1959, his revolution confiscated an estimated $1.8 billion in U.S.-owned
property from dozens of U.S. companies that
have been designated "certified claimants."
They include Exxon, Firestone, Sears, General
Electric, Coca-Cola, Colgate-Palmolive and others with claims now worth
more than $6 billion.
Title 3 also permits claims by Cuban-American
exiles who have become U.S. citizens, raising the estimated value of all
the property covered by the act to as
much as $100 billion.
"Title 3 is the teeth of the bill," said Ralph
Galliano, editor of the U.S.-Cuba Policy Report, which follows the property
compensation issue. "The Bush
administration has to assess the political cost of waiving."
Mr. Galliano said Cuban-Americans are looking
to the Bush administration for a significant gesture regarding Cuba´s
communist regime.
Mr. Bush named Mel Martinez, a Cuban-American,
as secretary of Housing and Urban Development. He nominated Otto Reich,
an anti-Castro
Cuban-American, to be assistant secretary of State for Latin America.
Mr. Bush also has invited dozens of prominent
Cuban-Americans, including the Cuban-American members of Congress and singer
Gloria Estefan, to the White
House to celebrate Cuban independence from Spain.
In addition, the president has signaled his
support for pending legislation to provide $100 million in U.S. assistance
over four years to dissidents on the island.
"All of that is greatly appreciated, but they
are symbols," said a Republican staff member on Capitol Hill. "Title 3
is the meat."