The Miami Herald
Tue, July 12, 2005

Ice pick surfaces; did it kill Trotsky?

The ice pick allegedly used to kill Leon Trotsky has appeared in Mexico, and it has prompted a confrontation between the owner and Trotsky's family.

BY MARK STEVENSON
Associated Press

MEXICO CITY - One of history's most infamous murder weapons, the ice pick allegedly used to kill Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky, has resurfaced after being lost for decades, just weeks before the 65th anniversary of his Aug. 20, 1940, assassination.

But tests that could prove the weapon's authenticity have been delayed by a dispute between the ice pick's owner, who is shopping it around, and Trotsky's descendants, who want it donated to a revolutionary museum.

The ice pick is in the possession of Ana Alicia Salas, whose father apparently removed it from an evidence room while serving as a secret police commander in the 1940s. She is toying with the idea of selling the foot-long, sawed-off ice ax, though she says she hasn't decided how much it's worth.

A few blocks away, Trotsky's grandson, who keeps the revolutionary flame alive by maintaining Trotsky's home as a museum, says he wants the pick.

Trotsky helped lead the 1917 Russian revolution, but split with dictator Josef Stalin and fled to Mexico in 1937, accusing Stalin of having betrayed the revolution.

Stalin is widely believed to have arranged Trotsky's murder, in which a young man posing as a sympathizer sneaked up behind Trotsky and sank the ice pick into his skull.

The murder weapon has become infamous, inspiring even the indie rock band Trotsky Icepick, whose songs included A Little Push At The Top Of The Stairs before the band stopped recording in the mid-1990s.

The weapon in Salas' possession still has faint, reddish-brown stains visible on its gleaming surface. But there's only one sure way to prove whether those stains are Trotsky's blood, and Esteban Volkov, Trotsky's grandson, holds the key: his DNA.

''Looking at it objectively, this is a piece of history,'' Volkov said in an interview at the home in the leafy Mexico City district of Coyoacan where Trotsky was killed, blocks from where Salas, the ice pick owner, also spoke to The Associated Press. ``It should be in the museum.''

Volkov, 79, has offered to give a sample of his own DNA for comparison to whatever material can be recovered from the pick, but only on the condition that Salas donate the artifact to the Trotsky museum here.

''If it is for commercial purposes, I refuse to participate in this kind of thing,'' Volkov said with disdain.

Salas, 50, refuses to consider such a donation, saying people only value the things they pay for.

In a country where police misconduct is legendary, Salas is quick to paint her father, Alfredo Salas, as a model secret service agent.

She said that Alfredo Salas, who retired in 1965 and died in 1985, had been granted permission by superiors to keep the ice pick in order to put together a ''museum of criminology.'' He withdrew the pick from the museum after someone tried to steal the artifact.