Mexico aims for expatriates' heartstrings and purse strings
Well-off U.S. migrants asked to assist in poor areas' development
BY ALFREDO CORCHADO and RICARDO SANDOVAL / The Dallas Morning News
Eduardo Nájera, a selfless scrambler on the basketball court, is an emerging hero for Dallas Mavericks fans.
Back home, a frayed neighborhood in the Mexican city of Chihuahua, Mr.
Nájera is already a big-time hero. But it is not for his rebounding
ability. Mr. Nájera is
among the high-profile Mexicans living in the United States involved
in a program that's donated millions of dollars for small-scale development
projects for poor
Mexicans.
Mr. Nájera has promised to raise at least $500,000 through a
series of celebrity basketball games and then monitor construction of recreation
centers and the
distribution of school scholarships.
It's part of an ambitious plan by Mexican President Vicente Fox to spark
economic development programs in the poorest of Mexican communities. His
goal is to tap
the growing wealth of Mexicans who've achieved financial success in
the United States.
"Eduardo is conscious about doing something to help his homeland, even
from Dallas, to help create opportunities for kids here in Mexico," said
Roberto González
Narozny, Mr. Nájera's business manager.
The so-called Padrino – godfather – project, also called "Adopt a Community,"
has captured the attention of U.S. officials and development officials
from other
countries. They see the program as an alternative to the traditional
and, often unsuccessful, approach of pouring money into central governments
and banks in poor
countries with the hope that some jobs might result.
"Mexicans living in the United States are turning the opportunities
to invest the money they send home into long-term economic development
projects," said Alan
Larson, U.S. undersecretary of state for economic, business and agricultural
affairs. "These projects could be strengthened by technical assistance,
small business
loans and an expansion of government grants to match migrant remittances."
U.S.-Mexican agreement
Economics adviser Eduardo Sojo and Juan Hernández, director of
the Presidential Office for Mexicans Abroad, designed Mr. Fox's plan. It
has proven so popular
in its early stages that the United States and Mexico have signed an
agreement – "Partners in Prosperity" – modeled on the idea of direct aid
to local development
projects.
The plan is getting attention this week in Monterrey, Mexico, where
hundreds of government and development officials are gathered for an international
forum on aid
to developing nations.
Expanding the development project – which some proponents have described
as every bit as important as the migration talks between Mexico and the
United States
– is also on the agenda of talks this week between Mr. Fox and President
Bush.
Mr. Fox is attempting to build on a successful program he backed while
governor of the central Mexican state of Guanajuato. Under that program,
migrants' money
was pooled and invested, along with matching funds from the state,
to establish small businesses. The jobs created by new businesses were
intended in large part to
keep young people and women from migrating.
Each year Mexican migrants in the United States send home billions of dollars.
The 2001 total was at least $9.3 billion, according to the Inter-American
Development Bank. Remittances are the third-most important source of foreign
income in
Mexico, behind exports of manufactured goods and oil.
In nudging Mexicans in the United States to invest in poor communities,
Mr. Fox is also mining a long-dormant desire by well-heeled migrants to
help their native
country.
"It's still about that special feeling you have for your homeland. It's
about giving back and showing we believe in a better Mexico," said Iris
Corral. Ms. Corral
migrated from Michoacán in western Mexico and is now spokeswoman
for Promotores Unidos, a Los Angeles-based group of entertainment industry
promoters
who represent some of the top names in norteño music.
Led by Los Tigres del Norte, perhaps the most popular of Mexican norteño
groups, Promotores Unidos has adopted the destitute village of Ichique
Balleza in
Mexico's southern state of Chiapas. It is the country's poorest region
and increasingly a producer of northbound migrants. The first project is
a series of new schools.
$50 million pledged
So far, 114 people and companies, which include large U.S. corporations,
have signed on as Padrinos, said Mr. Hernández, a former professor
at the University of
Texas at Dallas. They've pledged almost $50 million for job projects
and community development. The Mexican government will match some of that
money.
Eventually that money will be funneled to some 90 regions identified as the poorest and the heaviest exporters of U.S.-bound workers.
The typical projects fall into two categories: direct aid to communities for infrastructure, and grants or in-kind services for specific economic development plans.
Juan Francisco Ochoa falls into the first group. The founder of the
El Pollo Loco fast-food chain said that for years he's been eager to help
poor Mexicans but could
find no government official able to tell him how to invest.
"Everywhere I go in the United States, I find people like Mr. Ochoa
who were ready to help, but didn't know how, or never felt appreciated
by the Mexican
government," Mr. Hernández said.
Mr. Ochoa has put up $50,000 to bring electricity to the small town
of Juxtlahuaca, high in the mountains of Oaxaca state. He's never been
there, but thought it was a
good place to start what he hopes will be a long-term plan of finding
needy Mexican communities to assist.
"My goal is then to find migrants in the United States from the towns
I help, and push them toward taking more responsibility for creating jobs
back home, so fewer
of their families will try to make the dangerous migration journey,"
Mr. Ochoa said.
Carlos Olamendi, a Los Angeles-based entrepreneur, fits in the second
category. He used his marketing skills to help a coffee growers' cooperative
in Chiapas state
overcome a disastrous world coffee market. Prices for the cooperative's
organic coffee had fallen from $1.20 a bag to as low as 60 cents in recent
years.
But through an aggressive marketing campaign in the United States designed
by Mr. Olamendi, the cooperative's "Mayan Magic" brand has taken off and
now
commands about $2.50 a bag.
"They had no idea how to increase the value of the fine coffee they
were growing. All it took was some marketing," said Mr. Olamendi, a native
of Mexico City.
"This is the best way I can help. Instead of money, I've put my valuable
time and experience to work helping my native country. I hope it is an
example for others."
The adopt-a-community project is attractive, supporters say, because
it offers an alternative way of using aid money, which was often squandered
in the past by
corrupt and inefficient governments.
That's the nub of the emerging debate among representatives of developed
nations. Many have argued for increases in direct financial aid to developing
nations, while
others, like the Bush administration, are looking for alternatives.
Effect on migration
In Mexico, targeting poor villages may someday slow migration to the United States, officials say.
But some migration experts say that U.S. and Mexican officials are overly
optimistic. They doubt that Partners in Prosperity will add enough jobs
to stem the massive
annual flow of migrants in search of work north of the border.
"If they believe we can stop migration by creating a few low-paying
jobs in small towns, they will be disappointed," said Primitivo Rodríguez,
a migration expert with
the government of Mexico City. "The wage gap between the United States
and Mexico is too great. That's why people migrate. Until the wage gap
is narrowed,
people who want to go will go, regardless of the number of low-paying
factory jobs in their hometown."
Despite his doubts, Mr. Rodríguez is sure that plans like Mr. Fox's are headed in the right direction.
Ultimately, the efforts will be considered successful, Mr. Rodríguez
said, even if they simply provide jobs to the wives and children of migrants
– people who can be
kept from attempting to join their spouses in the United States.
"As a first step it is a good one, and it is a good way of channeling
the billions of dollars that today are underutilized as a source of investment
for economic
development," Mr. Rodríguez said.
Alfredo Corchado reported from Dallas and Washington, and Ricardo Sandoval reported from Mexico City and Tijuana, Mexico.