Plugging a Very Porous Northern Border
Since Sept. 11, More Agents, Technology Patrol Stretches of Long-Neglected 4,000-Mile Line
By Bill Miller
Washington Post Staff Writer
LYNDEN, Wash. -- A shallow ditch is all that separates Boundary Road,
which winds through the fields and farmhouses of
this dairy community, from 0 Avenue, a similar rural highway that parallels
it just 12 feet away -- in Canada. If not for a small
stone marker with "United States" on one side and "Canada" on the other,
the border between the two nations here would be
impossible to discern.
Where Boundary Road ends, rows of raspberry plants run right to the
border, offering cover to illegal immigrants and
smugglers toting backpacks filled with marijuana.
Before Sept. 11, 57 Border Patrol agents were responsible for this 120-mile
stretch of border in Washington state. In fact, until
the terrorist attacks on New York and Washington, the Border Patrol
had just 334 agents posted along the 4,000-mile
northern border, a fraction of its 9,500-member workforce.
Since then, the U.S.-Canadian border has received the kind of attention
that authorities have long spent on the boundary with
Mexico, where efforts to halt the flow of drugs and illegal immigrants
demanded it. Although the teeming points of entry present
their own kinds of problems, halting terrorists who might try to cross
these vast open stretches has become the focus of
increasing concern among homeland security authorities.
That puts the Border Patrol in a pivotal role: It is supposed to keep
people from entering the United States at places other than
official checkpoints. It is illegal to cross back and forth anywhere
else, no matter how inviting it seems.
The Justice Department's inspector general's office recently warned
that gaps remain along the northern border and said more
agents and technology are desperately needed. On Capitol Hill, Rep.
F. James Sensenbrenner Jr. (R-Wis.), chairman of the
House Judiciary Committee, has expressed concern about spotty enforcement.
As did Sen. Patty Murray (D-Wash.): "I am
very concerned, and have been for a very long time. I think the problems
up there are large and need to be dealt with."
Some former Border Patrol officials maintain that the Border Patrol
relies too heavily on cameras and sensors and has too few
agents to fully utilize the technology.
"I've never known a camera that can go down a pole and catch somebody,"
said Eugene R. Davis, former deputy chief patrol
agent of the U.S. Border Patrol here. "It's far from being secure.
If a person wants to come in, there are lots of places for them
to do it. There are still lots of holes." He noted that the sensors
can sound false alarms -- triggered by animals, for example --
and have other limitations. He remembers that "about 50 percent of
the time, we had nobody to respond to the sensors."
In response, hundreds of Border Patrol agents, immigration inspectors
and Customs Service personnel have been shifted north,
and more are on the way. By year's end, the Border Patrol will have
more than 600 agents along the northern border, and the
Bush administration wants to add 285 more in fiscal 2003.
About 700 National Guard troops recently began aiding inspectors at
the 124 northern ports of entry and are assisting the
Border Patrol with intelligence analysis and helicopter patrols. From
Washington to Maine, new tools are arriving, including
cameras, explosives detectors, radiation detectors and dogs.
Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge recently reached an agreement with
Canadian officials to share intelligence and expand
joint enforcement programs along the border. In addition, the Border
Patrol is building closer ties with leaders of Native
American tribes that live on border reservations.
John C. Bates, deputy chief patrol agent for the U.S. Border Patrol
here, acknowledged that coverage has not been beefed up
as much as he would like, but said technology helps fill in the gaps.
He said that sensors are hidden in fields, trees and other
places, capable of detecting movement. When tripped, they sound alarms
and illuminate computer terminals at a Border Patrol
command center in the nearby town of Blaine.
In recent weeks, a $5 million camera system capable of scanning 40 miles
of border was installed on 32 towering poles, meant
to complement the sensors. Technicians at the command center can swivel
the cameras and zoom in on objects up to four miles
away, helping authorities determine whether activated sensors were
set off by innocent farmers or schoolchildren, or by
someone who appears suspicious and requires immediate attention, Bates
said. Surveillance aircraft also patrol the area
regularly, he said.
Agents respond in four-wheel-drive vehicles, some with infrared cameras
mounted on their roofs. Bates said only so many
roads and trails lead away from the border and authorities can cut
them off. As he rode along Boundary Road recently, Bates
pointed to places where agents have caught illegal immigrants and found
drugs waiting for pickup, including backpacks filled
with marijuana. "We're able to get there," he said. "We use the technology
and the people and the information to get the job
done."
There is no evidence that any of the 19 terrorists who struck on Sept.
11 entered the United States from Canada. But
Canadian intelligence officials have estimated that about 50 terrorist
groups operate in Canada, including al Qaeda, Hamas and
the Irish Republican Army, and some allegedly have set up cells in
Vancouver, just 32 miles from Blaine.
Nevertheless, security along the northern border has been dwarfed by
the U.S. border presence in the Southwest for decades.
In a typical year, the Border Patrol apprehends 1.2 million people
in the Southwest; 12,000 in the north.
The Justice Department's inspector general's office reported in February
2000 that the Border Patrol "lacks the resources to
monitor illegal activity along the northern border." The report also
warned that "the porous nature of the border, coupled with
limited enforcement," limits chances of making arrests. In a follow-up
report released this February, the inspector general's
office said conditions are improving, but noted that chiefs of all
eight of the Border Patrol's northern sectors said they still
needed more agents, support staff and equipment.
Since Sept. 11, about 100 agents have been shifted from the southwestern
border and an effort to hire more has begun.
Twenty of the transferred agents work in Blaine, which now has a workforce
of 77. Congress has cleared the way to bring in
even more cameras, sensors and computers.
Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies,
which favors greater restrictions on immigration, said
the Border Patrol's strategy is sound as long as it receives more agents.
"The Border Patrol approach of leveraging their
personnel with technology is probably the way to go on the northern
border," he said.
In Washington state, the National Guard now provides a helicopter and
crew to conduct surveillance and shuttle agents to
remote areas. But the bulk of the enforcement is concentrated on a
44-mile stretch east of Blaine where the new cameras have
been located and where most of the sensors, which are moved from time
to time, are placed.
Rick Holleman, a Lynden resident who owns a trucking company, said he
can attest to the sensitivity of the sensors. "I jog
along the border every night, and just my jogging can set off the sensors,"
he said. A couple of months ago, a Border Patrol
agent -- just transferred from San Diego -- asked him what he was doing
running alongside Boundary Road. "It does seem like
there's more Border Patrol around," Holleman said, adding that agents
recently arrested two New York men near his home
after they were caught crossing the border with marijuana.
Carey James, who retired last year as chief patrol agent for the Border
Patrol in Blaine, said enforcers must worry not only
about the land border but also about nearby Puget Sound, where small
boats zip back and forth from Canada, often carrying
drugs.
The challenges in the north go well beyond geography, according to John
Frecker, the Northeast regional vice president of the
National Border Patrol Council, the union that represents border patrol
agents. Even when agents manage to catch people
crossing into the United States illegally, they have limited options,
he said. The criminal record checks they perform don't
extend worldwide and detention facilities are often so crowded that
the INS releases many illegal immigrants pending
deportation hearings. Then they disappear.
In Blaine, Border Patrol agents cite the case of Ghazi Ibrahim Abu Mezer,
a Palestinian who was caught three times in 1996
and 1997 in Washington state, only to be released each time. He was
sent back to Canada twice; the third time he was
released pending a deportation hearing. Mezer didn't show up for the
hearing but did turn up six months later in Brooklyn, New
York, where police arrested him in a plot to bomb subways. He was convicted
of conspiracy and sentenced to life in prison.
In the most famous case, Customs inspectors in Port Angeles, Wash.,
arrested Ahmed Ressam in December 1999 with a trunk
full of explosives. Ressam later admitted that he was part of a plot
to bomb Los Angeles International Airport and other targets
during millennium celebrations.
Security has been stepped up at Port Angeles, where inspectors are opening
more car trunks and looking at more trucks.
That's also true at the two ports of entry in Blaine, where the Customs
Service received new equipment to detect nuclear
materials and explosives.
Trucks are guided through a large scanning machine that alerts Customs
inspectors to hidden compartments or suspicious
cargo. A hand-held device can be used to find hidden panels in cars
and smaller trucks. The radiation detectors -- worn like
pagers -- are so sensitive that they are set off when someone undergoing
radiation treatments comes near.
Ronald H. Henley, Bates's boss and Blaine's chief patrol agent, said
he believes the extra security measures are working. He's
divided the region into 13 zones, regularly analyzes information coming
from the sensors, cameras, law enforcement and the
public, and is putting his agents in places where he believes they
can have the most impact.
"All I can say is I don't have any actual intelligence that hundreds of people are going where I'm not," Henley said.
© 2002