Latinos Recover Optimism Lost in '90s
Survey: More than 40% say the quality of life in Los Angeles has improved
in the last five years. However, a majority gave the
city's race relations poor marks.
By PATRICK J. McDONNELL, Times Staff Writer
Latinos in Los Angeles, who often felt under siege during California's
racially charged ballot initiative wars of the mid-1990s, have
generally recovered their optimism, according to a Los Angeles Times poll.
In the most dramatic illustration, Latinos surveyed in Los Angeles were
twice as likely as whites--and much more likely than
African Americans--to say quality of life has improved in the last five
years. L.A.'s emerging Latino majority is also more likely than
the white or black populations to assert that the city is headed in the
right direction.
And more than half of Latinos surveyed rated public school education as
adequate or excellent. By contrast, a majority of whites
and seven in 10 blacks said schools were inadequate or very poor. The positive
appraisal among Latinos persists even though Latino
children, who represent 70% of L.A.'s public school enrollment, often endure
the longest bus rides to school and the worst
overcrowding.
"It's the great paradox of Latino education: They are the strongest supporters
of public education, but public education is not
supporting them equally," said Harry Pachon, president of the Tomas Rivera
Policy Institute at Claremont Graduate University.
"Optimism is still alive in the barrios."
The Times poll, based on the responses of 1,570 residents interviewed between
Feb. 24 and March 1, also reflected deep
Latino apprehension about crime, police abuse and race relations. But analysts
said the most significant change was the level of basic
optimism.
Forty-three percent of Latinos said the quality of life in their communities
had improved in the past five years. That was a
strikingly more confident viewpoint than that of whites (21%) or blacks
(34%). It was by far the most positive reply by Latinos since
the quality-of-life question was first asked in Los Angeles by The Times
Poll in 1989. No more than 26% of Latinos had previously
responded affirmatively.
Several analysts attributed the response to sustained economic prosperity
and the relatively modest expectations of many
low-income immigrants from nations where public education is generally
neglected and government services are minimal.
But experts also cited the political turnaround from the mid-1990s, when
many Latinos--both immigrants and the
native-born--protested that they were being made scapegoats for a sluggish
economy and other societal woes.
The turmoil was set in motion in 1994 with Proposition 187, placed on the
ballot by citizens who contended that an influx of
illegal immigrants was sapping California's economy. Among other restrictions,
the measure would have forced schools and hospitals
to turn in suspected illegal immigrants.
Similar emotions festered through subsequent ballot initiatives that targeted
affirmative action and bilingual education. The
initiatives were often portrayed in the Spanish-language media as anti-Latino.
Those political campaigns helped trigger a profound, and unanticipated,
turnaround. Hundreds of thousands of Latino immigrants
opted to become U.S. citizens, resulting in the election of dozens of Latino
lawmakers and a dramatically altered political landscape.
Today, both major parties are wooing Latinos and immigrants in general,
spurring a renewed hopefulness among many.
"Now, I feel like we have a future here," said Miguel Carmona, a San Fernando
Valley painting contractor who was one of 519
Latinos interviewed in the poll. "I believe in America. I believe we can
do well."
Carmona, a 35-year-old Mexican immigrant, is a microcosm of the evolving
perspective. He said he became a citizen and voted
in his first national election in 1996 after becoming distressed by what
he called the anti-Latino politics of the mid-1990s. He now
exudes confidence and sees a bright future for his 6-year-old daughter,
Beverly Guadalupe (named after both Beverly Hills and the
patroness of Latin America), a public school first-grader.
"Latinos are no longer being attacked--in fact they are being used as a
symbol of American success," said Sergio Bendixen, a
longtime pollster of Latinos, now based in Miami. "People in California
don't realize the extent of what happened there in the '90s. It
was extraordinary, nothing short of a revolution."
A solid majority of Latinos, like blacks, called race relations in the
city "not so good" or poor. Whites, split on the subject, had a
more positive view. Moreover, Latinos were somewhat more skeptical about
the Los Angeles Police Department than other groups.
This may reflect charges of misconduct in the Rampart Division, which covers
a heavily immigrant Latino neighborhood west of
downtown. The well-publicized allegations that police routinely violated
the rights of young Latinos appeared to have delivered a
blow to the LAPD's image.
Thirty-one percent of Latinos disagreed with the statement that "most Los
Angeles police officers are hard-working and honest."
Latinos also joined blacks in solidly backing the imposition of federal
monitors to oversee the department.
The poll bared a deep preoccupation with crime--not surprising, experts
say, since many Latinos live in neighborhoods where
crime is endemic. Overall, 69% of Latinos called crime the most important
problem facing the city today, compared with 56% of
blacks and 43% of whites.
And while Latinos who are registered to vote were generally favorable to
Mayor Richard Riordan, they were more likely than
blacks or whites to say their neighborhoods were being "shortchanged" on
city services.
Latinos overall were almost equally divided when asked if the growing immigrant
population "is a good thing or a bad thing."
Behind this ambivalence, experts say, may lie a harsh economic fact: Latinos,
many concentrated at the low end of the income scale,
often suffer the most job competition from new immigrants.
The margin of sampling error for the poll was plus or minus 3 percentage
points.
Copyright 2001