Immigrants Set Out on Their Own Freedom Ride
Organizers hope to link undocumented workers' plight with the 1960s civil rights struggle.
By Nancy Cleeland
Times Staff Writer
The Rev. James Orange thought it had to be a joke. A new Freedom Ride ... for immigrants?
Orange, who earned his civil rights credentials in 1961 with a beating
in a Birmingham, Ala., bus station, couldn't imagine the idea of using
one of the most storied
moments in black history to promote the rights of immigrants, many
of them undocumented. But after a few long nights of conversation with
event organizers, the
60-year-old Atlanta minister started looking at things in a new way.
"When a worker is packed in the back of a truck and suffocates trying
to get across the border, or when someone comes through the airport and
gets detained just
because his name is Abdullah, those are civil rights issues," Orange
said. "The rights we fought for in the '60s are the same rights people
are fighting for now."
With the endorsement of African American leaders such as Orange, immigrant
workers across the nation are staging a new version of the Freedom Ride
this week.
The largest contingent, three full buses carrying 140 immigrant workers
and their supporters, is scheduled to leave Los Angeles today.
One of their chief goals is to win legal status for millions of undocumented
immigrants — something the campaign hopes to do by linking the plight of
immigrants with
the struggles of the civil rights movement.
Organizers of the new Freedom Ride have won backing from key groups
such as the National Assn. for the Advancement of Colored People and the
Congressional
Black Caucus, despite tensions between African Americans and undocumented
workers who often are competing for the same jobs. Those behind the journey
also
face pointed criticism from some who find it hard to see any connection
between today's undocumented workers and the heroic Freedom Riders of the
early '60s.
"Civil rights have nothing to do with the opening up of our borders,"
said David Ray, associate director of the Federation for American Immigration
Reform in
Washington. "They are riding on the coattails of a completely different
movement."
Whatever the case, the organizers recognize that they have little chance
of seeing quick success in Washington with their full agenda, especially
at a time when the
public is so concerned that an easing of restrictions at the border
may be exploited by terrorists.
The original Freedom Ride was undertaken in May 1961, when scores of
blacks and their white supporters rode buses across the South to challenge
segregation.
Violence ensued. One bus was firebombed, and riders were beaten.
The latest incarnation promises to be a far more peaceful affair. In
all, 18 buses are departing from 10 cities on a route that will make more
than 100 stops. Among
them: Tucson, where riders will pay tribute to lost border crossers,
and the Memphis, Tenn., hotel where Martin Luther King Jr. was shot.
All the participants will meet up in Washington for a rally and visit
to Congress, and then converge on Oct. 4 at Flushing Meadows Park in New
York, where
organizers hope to draw 100,000 supporters to a closing ceremony.
The riders from Los Angeles include Maggie Larson, a Malaysian immigrant
and hotel housekeeper who traveled from Hawaii; Mexican-born restaurant
worker
Rocio Rojas, who lives in L.A.; and Donte Woods, a 26-year-old African
American activist with the Community Coalition, a South Los Angeles nonprofit.
Linking civil rights and immigrant rights is "a brilliant political
strategy," said Roger Waldinger, chairman of UCLA's sociology department.
"What they're emphasizing
is the humanity, that these are people just like you and me, and they
deserve fundamental rights."
The campaign was born two years ago at a brainstorming session by leaders
of the hotel workers union, who were looking for ways to dramatize their
push for
immigration reform.
Since then, the ride has grown into something potentially much more
significant as organizers have sought to redefine the quest for legalization
by millions of
undocumented immigrants, from Haiti to Nigeria to Mexico.
Along the way, the effort has become a significant moment in the relations
between African Americans and undocumented immigrants, especially in places
such as
Southern California. As part of the preparations for the Freedom Ride,
training sessions held during the last year have opened immigrants' eyes
to the sacrifices made
by young black activists a generation ago.
"To see how badly they were treated — one of the buses was even burned
— it gives you a lot to think about. There's a lot to admire," said 46-year-old
Rojas, the
restaurant worker. "It's not exactly the same for us. We don't have
to go to the back of the bus. But still there is no respect at work, and
we always, always live with
fear."
Proponents of the immigrants' ride knew from the beginning that their idea had the potential to stir resentment.
Unlike African Americans battling for equality, after all, some of the
immigrants on this latest trip entered the country and obtained jobs illegally
— sometimes
competing for the same low-skilled jobs being sought by many blacks.
And so the ride's advocates — led by Maria Elena Durazo, president of
Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Local 11 in Los Angeles — spent
months in
private conversation with black leaders. "We wanted to be respectful,"
she said. "We had a lot of one-on-one conversations. If, in the end, people
thought it was
wrong, we wouldn't have done it."
One of her first contacts was with the Rev. Jim Lawson, who had trained
many of the original Freedom Riders in nonviolent resistance and was himself
arrested in
Jackson, Miss.
Lawson, 75, who is president of the Los Angeles chapter of the Southern
Christian Leadership Conference, not only endorsed the ride; he became
one of its leading
advocates. Still, he concedes, his feelings aren't universally shared.
"There are some feelings in the black community that immigrant workers
are not a valid concern," he said. "This is a beginning. It's a step to
launch a new
conversation."
Waldinger, the UCLA professor, agreed. Just because some black leaders
have endorsed the immigrants' Freedom Ride, he noted, it doesn't necessarily
mean that the
community at large will be supportive.
"The leadership sees the broader issue, but the rank-and-file has more
difficulty wrestling with two opposing feelings," said Waldinger, who noted
that there was strong
support among blacks for California's anti-illegal immigration measure,
Proposition 187.
Sensitive to this reality, organizers are trying to use each of the
103 scheduled stops along the Freedom Ride to show that African Americans
and immigrants share
many of the same concerns. In Mississippi and North Carolina, for example,
union organizers plan to tell riders that local employers — a retailer
and a hog processor
— are trying to leverage tensions, pitting one group against the other
to avoid bargaining for a contract.
That pragmatic approach has persuaded some reluctant black unionists
to endorse the ride. "Since they are here, they might as well have certain
rights," said Willie
Robinson, president of the Coalition of Black Trade Unionists in Southern
California. "It might eliminate them from being scabs."
During the 50 or so hours of road time, riders will be immersed in civil
rights history, with videos and lectures that try to make the link back
to immigration issues.
Buses will stop at all the major points of conflict in 1961, including
the spots where a bus was run off the road and burned; the bridge where
riders were met by a mob
wielding pipes and baseball bats; and the Birmingham bus station where
Orange was beaten as he tried to meet up with the original riders.
Meanwhile, advocates of tighter borders are planning a counter demonstration. That event is set for Oct. 3 at Liberty Park in New Jersey.
Times staff writer Teresa Watanabe contributed to this report.