More gay immigrants seeking refuge in U.S.
New rules, groups aid asylum quests
JOHNNY DIAZ
Matthew Ramos' eyes widen and water like a scared deer's when
he speaks of
the name-calling and the beatings that forced him to flee his
native Brazil.
``They would beat me with clubs wrapped in towels so they wouldn't
leave marks.
They called me bicha (a derogatory term for a gay man in Portuguese).
They
followed me in my car and stopped me for nothing,'' recalls the
24-year-old of the
harassment and humiliation he endured from police in Brazil's
capital city who
knew he was gay.
Desperate and scared, he e-mailed and called the Dade Human Rights
Foundation, a Miami-based advocacy group that supports gay and
lesbian
causes.
When he showed up at their front door, his story became the catalyst
for a South
Florida task force that recently formed to help a small but growing
number of gay
and lesbian immigrants seeking asylum on U.S. shores.
Unlike a little over 10 years ago -- when U.S. laws barred gay
men and lesbians
from settling in the country -- Ramos' request for asylum based
on his sexual
orientation was granted by Immigration and Naturalization Service
agents in
Miami.
Experts say approving such applications represents a relatively
new rethinking of
the asylum laws once reserved for religious and political applicants,
and a
new-found recognition that gay and lesbian asylum seekers are
members of a
social class that has been persecuted.
As more people learn about their eligibility for asylum based
on their sexual
orientation, immigration officials and advocates foresee a rise
in their numbers --
through word of mouth or through task forces that have formed
nationwide to help
them.
``We will undoubtedly see more sexual-orientation asylum cases,''
said David
Abraham, an immigration law professor at the University of Miami.
``America's
readiness to see gender and sexual orientation for the basis
of granting asylum
has been steadily growing as the gay rights movement in the United
States has
scored significant political and cultural victories.''
Some 41,000 people applied for U.S. asylum during fiscal year
2000; about
17,000 of those were granted. Because the INS does not keep records
detailing
the reasons applicants seek asylum, it's difficult to say how
many of the new
arrivals are claiming such oppression.
The new wave of asylum seekers hails from around the globe, although
those who
settle in South Florida are primarily from nearby Latin America
and the Caribbean.
Examples of the persecution they face in their homelands are numerous.
The San
Francisco-based International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission,
a
watchdog group that documents crimes and abuses against gay people
worldwide, reports:
On Nov. 19, a transvestite walking with a male companion
died after being
gunned down in San Salvador. Seven similar murders were reported
in 1999; 12 in
1998. In one of the 1999 incidents, five men dressed in black
fired shots from a
moving taxi at a 37-year-old man who had left a bar with two
other men, one of
them wearing women's clothing.
In Romania, two men were beaten and faced imprisonment
for kissing and
holding hands in public. Other hot spots for anti-gay assaults
and raids are
Mexico, Russia, Japan and Pakistan. In Cuba, gays can be imprisoned.
In Iran,
they can be executed.
``In some of these countries, it's very oppressive and often times
[gays] have to
keep it a secret. Their families reject them,'' said M. Ross
Seligson, a Nova
Southeastern University professor and Fort Lauderdale psychologist
with gay
clientele from Latin America.
``They come here for the same reason many people come here --
the language,
the large gay community and the weather. It's easier to assimilate
in places
where there are a lot of similarities,'' he added.
SALVADORAN CASE
U.S. immigration officials in Maryland granted a 28-year-old gay
Salvadoran man
asylum in November. He said he had been beaten and sexually assaulted
by
police officers in his home country.
Two Colombian men -- whose applications for asylum were approved
by the INS in
Miami in November -- said they were routinely jailed and hosed
down, beaten up,
even shot at after officers in Bogotá discovered they
were lovers. They now live in
Hollywood where one works as a nurse and the other is a pharmacy
technician.
Clark Reynolds, outgoing executive director of the Dade human
rights group, said
the idea of forming a Miami task-force chapter came after Ramos,
the Brazilian
immigrant, and the Colombian couple showed up at his office seeking
help.
The South Florida chapter of the New York-based Lesbian and Gay
Immigration
Rights Task Force is one of 15 chapters nationwide.
The Miami chapter is made up of a network of immigration attorneys
and
advocates who can answer questions and assist would-be immigrants
with the
asylum application process. A key goal: getting the word out
to immigrant groups
that help is available. Brochures in English, Spanish, Creole
and Portuguese
explaining the task force's mission are being printed for distribution
in the coming
months.
``It's scary to think of all the immigrants here who don't know
they have the option
to apply for asylum here if they have been persecuted in their
native country,''
Reynolds added.
But immigration advocates are quick to point out that being gay
should not be the
only grounds for winning asylum.
``Just because you are gay does not mean you are going to get
asylum,'' says
Bill Strassberger, a spokesman for the INS in Washington, D.C.
``You are going
to get [asylum] because you have proven you are fleeing persecution
and/or you
have a well-founded fear of persecution if you return to your
country.''
As in all asylum cases, there is a potential for fraud among applicants.
There are
also hurdles that range from applicants documenting their same-sex
orientation to
proving they were persecuted in their native countries. The biggest
hurdle of all for
some of the applicants may be coming out of secrecy and telling
immigration
officials they are gay.
The INS documents persecution through a series of oral interviews
and written
testimonies with asylum officials. Police incident reports, medical
records that
show injuries and documentation of human rights violations from
certain countries
are other means would-be immigrants could present for their cases,
Strassberger
added.
``No one would have imagined 20 years ago that sexual orientation
would have
been a valid basis for asylum,'' said Abraham, the UM immigration
law professor.
He noted that a U.S. law barring gay men and lesbians from settling
in the
country was repealed in 1990.
Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, a person can be granted
asylum if he
or she establishes a well-founded fear of persecution because
of race, religion,
nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular
social group.
The latter category was clarified in 1994 when then-Attorney General
Janet Reno
said persecution based on sexual orientation can be grounds for
asylum.
Reno's action broadened the significance of a decision by an immigration
review
panel in 1990 in a case involving Fidel Armando Toboso-Alfonso,
a Cuban who
sought political asylum in 1986 on the grounds that he had long
been persecuted
because he was gay.
For Ramos, the Brazilian, his fear of retaliation from police
officers -- against
family members and others still in Brazil -- is so great that
he asked that his real
name not be used for this article.
BAD MEMORIES
By his account, Ramos' problems began in September 1999 in his
native Brasília,
the capital of Brazil. He and his boyfriend were sitting in a
parked car ``holding
hands'' when police officers banged on the car window and dragged
them out. The
officers roughed them up with clubs wrapped in towels.
``I just wanted to run away, It's like when you are in a burning
building -- you just
run. I wanted to save my life,'' Ramos said.
While browsing the Internet looking for help, he stumbled upon
the Dade Human
Rights Foundation website.
Ramos obtained a visa in Brazil, flew to Miami and called Reynolds last May.
He hopes one day to return home, but he says for now, ``I'm doing
well. I'm
starting to be happy again.''