U.S. banks, cities accept Mexican illegals' ID
Carter Dougherty
THE WASHINGTON TIMES
A Mexican identification card used chiefly
by illegal immigrants is being accepted by a growing number of U.S. banks
and cities.
Bill Strassberger, a spokesman for the Immigration
and Naturalization Service, stressed that holders of the card, known as
the "matricula consular," should not
confuse it for a residency permit. But he said no law or regulation
prevents banks or cities from using it.
"It's strictly an identification document,"
he said. "If banks choose to accept it, that does not make it an immigration
matter."
For more than a century, Mexican consulates
around the world have offered the card to Mexican citizens. But its use
in the United States has picked up steam
during the past year as U.S. banks such as Wells Fargo, Bank of America
and Citibank, eager to manage the $60 billion earned by undocumented workers
each
year, have begun accepting it for checking accounts.
Elected officials in major U.S. cities, including
Los Angeles, Chicago and San Francisco, have followed by accepting the
ID for use in city business such as
borrowing books from libraries, entering municipal buildings and minor
scrapes with the police.
"This program has gone completely beyond my
expectations," said Martha Lara, the Mexican consul general in Los Angeles
who has lobbied U.S. officials for its
acceptance.
Every month in Los Angeles alone, the consulate
churns out 15,000 cards. The 47 other Mexican consulates in the United
States, especially those close to the
border, hand out thousands more.
The Mexican Consulate in Washington, where
most Hispanics hail from Central and South America, issues about 450 cards
each month, said spokesman Miguel
Monterrubio.
The card is a straightforward ID that includes
a person's photograph and address in the United States. During the past
year, Mexican authorities have phased in
additional security features, such as a hologram, to thwart forgeries.
Cardholders are widely recognized to be in
the United States illegally, as official residence would give them access
to American-issued identification, such as a
driver's license.
A broad coalition supports the use of the
cards. Police forces are happy to have a reliable ID for noncitizens. Hispanic
civil rights groups seeking better treatment
for Mexicans have cheered it. The Mexican government, mindful of the
close attention being paid to immigrants since the September 11 terrorist
attacks, has pushed
the card as a way to protect its citizens.
A few groups who favor tighter immigration
laws have criticized it.
"It makes life easier for illegal immigrants,
and that compromises law enforcement and security," said Mark Krikorian,
executive director of the Center for
Immigration Studies in Washington. "It's a creeping amnesty that incorporates
illegal aliens into our institutions."
The roughly 3 million illegal immigrants in
the United States earn about $60 billion each year, making them a rich
potential market for American banks, according
to the Manuel Orozco of the Inter-America Dialogue, a Washington think
tank.
"One of our key target markets is Hispanics,"
said Ken Preston, a spokesman for Charlotte, N.C.-based Bank of America,
which has honored the card since
December. "They have traditionally been underserved."
In addition to accepting the matricula, Bank
of America has invested $40 million in a Spanish-language advertising campaign.
It also offers a service that allows
customers to send money to Mexico.
San Francisco-based Wells Fargo, which in
November became the first bank in the nation to accept the ID, has used
the card to open 35,000 checking accounts
that now hold about $50 million in deposits.
The card, with a taxpayer identification number
— an Internal Revenue Service number available to noncitizens — is enough
to open an account. The fact that
most of the applicants are in the United States illegally does not
matter.
"We do not question the legal status of any
of our customers," said Mary Trigg, a Wells Fargo spokeswoman.
The impetus for using the card came from law
enforcement, especially the police department in Austin, Texas. Nearly
half of all robberies in Austin in 2000 were
committed against undocumented Mexican workers, including four robbery-homicides.
"This population was getting robbed [because]
they cannot put their money in a bank," Assistant Police Chief Rudy Landeros
said.
In 2001, after discussions that included Wells
Fargo, Austin city officials and Mexican consular authorities, the bank
agreed to accept the card at area branches.
Convinced that the card helped reduce crime, Austin began training
police officers to recognize and accept the ID.
Chief Landeros conceded that most of the Mexicans
who carry the card are in the United States illegally but said the reduction
in robberies made the card an
invaluable tool.
"We are focused on public safety, not immigration,"
he said. "Our job is to protect and serve, regardless of immigration status."
Following the Austin program, Mexican officials,
including Mrs. Lara, went to work in Southern California to win acceptance
for the card.
Wells Fargo also took a closer look
at how the Mexican government issues the ID and what it does to prevent
forgery.
"We had extensive talks with the Mexican consulate
on the security issues," Ms. Trigg said. "The card has all the things it
needs to be a primary identification."
On Nov. 7, Wells Fargo announced that the
card would be valid ID at all bank locations in 23 states, triggering a
wave of interest by other financial services
companies.
"Three hours later, faxes were rolling into
my office [from banks] saying they would accept it too," Mrs. Lara said.