Independent Libraries Mix Politics, Culture in Cuba
By Karen DeYoung
HAVANA –– The thousand or so bedraggled books stacked on the dusty floor
and sagging shelves of Ricardo Gonzalez's
single, sunlit room are an eclectic mixture. There are some paperback
novels, biographies of Jose Marti and the "Thoughts of
Fidel Castro." There are Cuban authors banned for ancient and forgotten
reasons, and a shelf of poetry.
The Jorge Manach Independent Library, named for a once-famous journalist
in a different, long-ago Cuba, is open to lend, but
there are few borrowers.
"Sometimes [Communist] Party youth come here," said Gonzalez, a former
government journalist with a booming voice and a
ready laugh. "Not many, because they're scared. We're really just a
service to the community, but some in the community are
scared. Of course, some people just come for the prohibited books,
and ask for them by name. Whoever comes, no matter
what they think, if we have the book, they can have it. I don't care
what they take. People have the right to read."
Actually, getting your hands on a book that the government has decided
you do not need to read can be difficult here. Although
Cuba has an extensive network of state and school libraries and what
Gonzalez says is one of the Third World's best technical
collections, admission is often restricted, and access to certain volumes
is determined by a need-to-know color code.
Having and reading books on your own is not a crime in Cuba. But it
can draw always-risky attention. The government seems
to decide on an ad hoc basis what is not permitted--the recent seizure
of 11 books from another of Havana's independent
lenders included a volume on Cuba's agricultural system and "Short
Stories From Here and There," along with some Catholic
magazines.
The first independent libraries began when a few intellectuals decided
to take Castro at his word when the Cuban president
said in a 1998 speech that "there are no banned books in Cuba--there
just isn't any money to buy them." Gathering old,
moldering volumes forgotten or hidden in pre-revolutionary collections,
they set them on shelves and opened their doors.
Books are donated by Cubans leaving the country, and occasionally a
sympathizer abroad will send a few new volumes by air
freight--although that heightens the risk of arbitrary seizure by customs
agents.
Gonzalez estimates that about 50 independent libraries are scattered
around the country--some general interest, some devoted
to specialized topics such as women's issues, the history of the North
American Revolution, agrarian literature or music.
Although each library is aware of others, they remain autonomous, lest
they be perceived as forming a prohibited "movement."
Other than occasional seizures or a rare shutdown, however, the government
largely leaves them alone.
"This isn't a political undertaking, it's a cultural one," Gonzalez
said. "But of course, in these conditions, it's hard to separate the
coffee from the milk in your cafe con leche." In Cuba, all things are
political.
"For instance, look at this book--'Mea Cuba,' a play on the words 'mea
culpa.' It was written by Guillermo Cabrera Infante, a
winner of the Cervantes Prize. . . . The book was published in the
early 1960s, but it is prohibited. He was the Cuban cultural
attache in Belgium and broke with the government and started to criticize
it. This book is his thoughts and remembrances" about
pre- and post-revolutionary life here. The author, Gonzalez said, "is
more controversial than the book."
"Here's 'The Works of Che Guevara,' and 'Nation and State in Liberal
Spain'--that one's not allowed. If somebody comes in
and asks about human rights, here's the official version, 'Cuba and
Human Rights.' Here's another version, published by
UNESCO. It's prohibited. I show them both, and I don't care which one
they take."
"We have only two rules for books," he said. "No racism and no violence."
There are also books by Jorge Manach, including his biography of Marti,
the father of Cuban liberation. Manach "was an
author and a politician in the pre-revolution times," Gonzalez said.
"In the 1920s, he was one of the greatest Cuban
journalists--he was always intransigent against any dictatorship."
When Castro was imprisoned by Fulgencio Batista in the
1950s, Gonzalez said, he wrote letters to Manach.
"But he died in exile in 1961," he said of the library's namesake. "For the Cuban government, it's like he never existed."