Border deaths up despite apparent dip in crossings
Remains of 128 found in past six months
ARTHUR H. ROTSTEIN
The Associated Press
Illegal immigrant deaths have risen along the U.S.-Mexico border in
the past six months despite a nearly 25 percent drop in Border Patrol arrests
that suggests far fewer people are entering the country unlawfully.
The number of migrant deaths along the roughly 2,000-mile border increased
by nearly 7 percent between Oct. 1 and March 31, the first six months of
the 2009 federal fiscal year. The biggest increase occurred in the patrol's
Tucson sector, the nation's busiest corridor for illegal immigrants coming
through Mexico.
In all, the remains of 128 people were found, compared to 120 in the
same six-month period the year before, according to just-released Border
Patrol statistics.
Yet apprehensions of people crossing illegally from Mexico into Texas,
New Mexico, Arizona and California dropped to less than 265,000 – a decrease
of more than 24 percent from the comparable period a year ago and 37 percent
from the first six months of the federal fiscal year that began on Oct.
1, 2006. The number of arrests is generally considered an indication of
how many people are illegally crossing the border into the U.S. The more
apprehensions, the more people are thought to be coming.
Migrants rights groups say there's a direct correlation between the
number of deaths and increased enforcement along the U.S.-Mexico border.
"What we've seen is that the death rate has gone up even though the
number of people crossing has gone down, the direct result of more agents,
more fencing and more equipment," said the Rev. Robin Hoover, founder of
the Tucson-based group Humane Borders, which provides water stations for
migrants crossing the southern Arizona desert. "The migrants are walking
in more treacherous terrain for longer periods of time, and you should
expect more deaths."
Nearly half the dead were found in the Border Patrol's rugged Tucson
sector, which saw a 30 percent increase from the same period a year earlier.
Deaths also rose in the Laredo and Del Rio sectors in Texas, and in the
El Centro sector of southwestern California.
No sector approached Tucson's sheer numbers, where the remains of 60
people were found during the first half of the 2009 fiscal year.
Tucson sector Border Patrol spokesman Omar Candelaria said it was hard
to say why deaths increased in his area, especially because they're not
being found in summer, when most deaths occur.
He also said it is difficult to determine how long many of the bodies
may have been there because many were skeletal remains.
Dr. Bruce Parks, the medical examiner in southern Arizona's Pima County,
said more than half the bodies his office examined were skeletal remains,
meaning they had not died recently. But that is down from first half of
fiscal 2008, when 75 percent of the cases involved skeletal remains.
"Many of them are people that died sometime earlier, and it could be
more than a year or two in some cases," Parks said. "It would make sense
that you would expect the more apprehensions there are reflects a greater
number of people crossing, and the more crossings the greater the number
of deaths that should follow."
Parks' office also conducts autopsies for several other Arizona counties
including Santa Cruz, Pinal and occasionally Yuma — all of which have regularly
seen illegal immigrant deaths.
Weather, predominantly in the form of unrelenting late-spring and summer
triple-digit heat, is often the key factor in illegal immigrant deaths
in Arizona.
Hypothermia from frigid wintry conditions in the desert also occasionally
can be fatal for unprepared desert crossers, Parks said.
Hoover said he's measured where the bodies are being found, and the
average death locations are farther and farther away from roads than in
previous years.
"So they're going around the fences, the technology and where the agents
are," he said. "And the farther you walk from a safe place, the more likely
a broken ankle becomes a death sentence."