Block committees sound alarm in Venezuela
Leading candidate's camp denies emulating Cuba
By TIM JOHNSON
Herald Staff Writer
CARACAS -- The movement supporting presidential front-runner Hugo Chavez
plans to set up political committees on every block, in every factory,
on every
ranch and in every classroom across Venezuela.
To the opponents of the populist former coup leader, the plan smacks of
the
neighborhood ``snoop'' committees that keep a lid on dissent in Cuba.
A top aide to Chavez says not to fear: The committees won't serve as social
monitors -- or worse, political police. They will only allow Venezuelans
from all
walks of life to contact the Fifth Republic Movement (MVR) that Chavez
founded,
and perhaps channel observations about corruption to the proper authorities.
``They won't have any function like watching or controlling the citizenry
that could
be associated with what happens in Cuba. Absolutely not,'' said Hector
Davila, the
movement's national secretary for electoral matters.
Opponents have used the issue to attack Chavez as he comes within striking
distance of capturing the presidency in Dec. 6 elections. Polls say Chavez
is the
clear front-runner. Chavez expressed admiration for Cuban President Fidel
Castro
in a visit to Havana in late 1994, but has moved toward the political center
to
consolidate his support.
Name is similar
Some Venezuelans are uneasy, though, over the movement's explanation of
the
committees. For one thing, there is the name. According to the official
charter of
the Fifth Republic Movement, the political committees are called Networks
of
People's Power. People's Power also happens to be the name of a Cuban elected
body.
Asked about the similarity, Davila shrugged.
``The Cubans don't have a copyright on the word `people,' '' he said.
The wording of the charter's Article 18 indicates that the committees will
be
ubiquitous: ``Two or more primary activists of the Movement . . . will
establish the
Networks of People's Power on every block, residential compound or building,
classroom, factory, office, store, business, hamlet, ranch, plaza or wherever
else
there is a concentration of people.''
In Cuba, citizens are obligated to take part in neighborhood groups, called
Committees for the Defense of the Revolution, that are the eyes and ears
of the
Communist Party. The groups are known for meddling in the affairs of the
citizenry, although their activity has lapsed somewhat in recent years.
Similar watchdog groups were established by the Sandinistas in Nicaragua
from
1979 until 1990, and were widely loathed by Sandinista opponents.
A lack of concern
Some analysts think the Fifth Republic Movement's committees will never
amount
to much. They dismiss any concerns.
``Some of the leftists who surround Chavez and are accustomed to the Leninist
way of forming parties went overboard on this,'' said Vladimir Gessen,
a
psychologist and political commentator.
Gessen noted that many political parties in Venezuela have hierarchical
structures
and a broad grass-roots presence across the country.
``Democratic Action has a cell in every township,'' Gessen said, referring
to the
dominant center-left party. ``And if they could put one on every block,
in every
house, they'd do it, too.''
A Chavez spokesman, Carlos Enrique Tinoco, offered the same comparison.
``The Democratic Action party that was formed by Romulo Betancourt, the
father
of Venezuelan democracy, also has neighborhood committees, committees in
every housing development, union hall, etc.,'' he said. ``No one has ever
asked
them why they have committees everywhere.''
Disparate elements
The leadership of Chavez's movement comprises an array of radical leftists,
nationalists and military hard-liners. The movement has surged on a wave
of
discontent among those who feel that the political system is unresponsive
to the
majority of Venezuela's 24 million people.
Perhaps because Chavez has evoked deep mistrust among some Venezuelans,
fears have not been assuaged over the role of the grass-roots committees.
``This seems dictatorial to me. . . . They can seek to retaliate against
you. Those
who sit on a committee can denounce their neighbors,'' said Mercedes Girona,
an
unemployed philosopher.
``It's evil,'' said Ladislao Iturriza, a sociology student. ``He wants
the same thing as
Castro in Cuba, to control all movement on the streets.''
Chavez supporters dismiss suggestions that the committees might help an
eventual
Chavez government impose authoritarian controls.
An eye on corruption
``Communism will never take root here. It has ended in Latin America forever,''
said Bartolome Vasquez, a taxi driver and Chavez supporter.
He said he favored the grass-roots political committees because they may
help
Chavez -- if he wins elections -- root out bureaucratic corruption that
they say is
eating away at the government.
``The idea is to get rid of corruption, to separate those who are stealing
from those
who are not,'' he said.
Davila, the campaign official, said anti-corruption efforts may be only
an incidental
part of the committees' work.
``Their function will be political organizing,'' he said. ``Look, it's
not much different
from other parties in Venezuela.''