Study details how Cuban exiles have aided key U.S. lawmakers
By ALFREDO CORCHADO / The Dallas Morning News
WASHINGTON – A small group of foreign citizens has sought for four decades
to influence policy on Cuba through hefty political contributions to lawmakers
who
share their anti-Castro views, according to a study by critics of U.S.
policy.
Much of the money comes from wealthy business executives whose vast fortunes in Cuba were seized by Fidel Castro after he took power in 1959.
The study was conducted independently by Cynthia Thomas, a Dallas public
policy analyst for TriDimension Strategies and a member of the executive
committee of
Americans for Humanitarian Trade With Cuba, a group dedicated to normalizing
relations.
The report offers the most detailed list matching recipients with individual
Cuban-American contributors and Free Cuba PAC, which handles direct political
contributions on behalf of the Cuban American National Foundation.
Between Jan. 1, 1999, and Feb. 28, 2002, the combined individual and
corporate contributions by the Cuban-American business executives was an
estimated $1.8
million, she said. More than 70 percent of the $1.8 million came from
the brothers who run the Bacardi Martini rum company.
An earlier study by the Center for Responsive Politics, a nonpartisan
group, illustrated a similar pattern between donors and recipients, though
it didn't completely
identify the full list of contributors. The two studies illustrate
some of the possible influences on the policy that President Bush is expected
to tighten even more in a
speech scheduled for Monday.
The findings of the two studies buttress a long-held belief among critics
of U.S. policy to Cuba that the policy remains a Cold War obsession fueled
in part by
campaign contributions from those with personal interests in the island.
"When U.S. foreign policy becomes personal it can also become dangerous,"
said Eric P. Farnsworth, a former Clinton foreign policy adviser on Latin
American
affairs. "Cuba is an example of that."
Effect on policy denied
State Department officials denied that either politics or votes influence their policy to Cuba.
"What drives U.S. foreign policy to Cuba is our deeply held commitment
to helping the Cuban people achieve the same basic rights and freedoms
that are enjoyed in
every other country in the hemisphere," said Wes Carrington, a spokesman
for the State Department's bureau on Western Hemisphere Affairs.
The Federal Election Commission says that noncitizens can make contributions if they are legal U.S. residents.
Ms. Thomas said that few foreign citizens play a more active role in
seeking to influence U.S. foreign policy than the Bermuda-based Bacardi
Martini rum company
and sugar barons Alfonso and Jose Fanjul. The Cuban-born brothers,
better known as Alfy (a Democrat) and Pepe (a Republican), are Spanish
citizens but have
homes in West Palm Beach, Fla.
Of the $1.8 million contributed between 1999 and 2002, the Fanjul brothers;
their corporation, Flo-Sun Sugar; and Bacardi contributed $1.34 million,
or 71 percent
of the total.
"The debate on this delicate and important issue is being colored by
people who can't even vote in this country," Ms. Thomas said. She noted
that the contributions
also serve to help them gain access to lobby for federal price subsidies.
The Helms-Burton Act
The Fanjul brothers, who did not return several calls placed to their
West Palm Beach homes and offices, and their corporation together control
about 40 percent of
Florida's sugar crop. They made contributions to 39 political candidates
and committees, among them the 2000 presidential candidates George W. Bush
and Al
Gore, with $2,000 and $1,000 respectively.
The company Bacardi Martini, which contributed nearly $400,000, was
among those who sought through contributions to influence enactment of
the 1996
Helms-Burton law, which tightened the U.S. embargo on Cuba and allowed
Cuban-Americans to sue foreign companies using, or investing in, expropriated
properties in Cuba.
The authors of the law, Sen. Jesse Helms, R-N.C., and Dan Burton, R-Ind.,
both received substantial contributions from the executives. Before 1990,
according to
the Center for Responsive Politics, Mr. Burton hadn't received a penny
from Cuban-Americans. By 1996, he had received more than $61,000 from
Cuban-Americans individuals and companies, including Bacardi, the center
reported.
Similarly, 74 percent of the $86,000 Mr. Helms has received from those
groups and individuals came in 1995 and 1996, "while Helms was running
for re-election
and the Helms-Burton Act was before Congress," according to the center's
report.
"We're not saying that money comes in forms of bribes for votes," said
Steven Weiss, a spokesman Center for Responsive Politics. "But contributions
buy access.
They buy face time."
Since 1997 neither Mr. Burton nor Mr. Helms has received a contribution. Their representatives did not return calls seeking comment on the contributions.
The person now in charge of enforcing the Helms-Burton law is Mr. Bush's
top Latin American diplomat, Otto J. Reich. He helped write the bill and
also worked as
a paid Bacardi lobbyist from 1997 to 2000, according to the Center
for Responsive Politics.
Split between parties
Ms. Thomas listed 99 individual contributors to Free Cuba (for contributions
of $200 or more); 74 individual recipients, including both Republicans
and Democrats;
and 17 political action committees. Between 1999 and February 2002,
Republicans and Democrats generally split the contributions, with Republicans
receiving
about $909,595 and Democrats getting $882,399, her report said.
Among the top PAC recipients was the Republican National Committee with
$465,300 – with $337,500 coming from Flo-Sun Sugar. The Democratic National
Committee received $246,250 – with the Fanjul corporation contributing
$185,000.
The Fanjul name lives on both sides of the Florida Straits. In Havana,
where a street is named after their grandfather, some people call the Fanjuls
powerful and
arrogant. At one time, according to Cuban historians, the Fanjuls'
father, Alfonso Fanjul Sr., and their grandfather, Jose Gomez-Mena, presided
over one of the
largest sugar holdings in Cuba, more than 150,000 acres and 10 sugar
mills.
Today, their childhood home is one of Mr. Castro's homes. After their
father lost one of Cuba's great sugar fortunes to Mr. Castro's revolution,
the brothers built a
new empire in Florida, importing cheap Jamaican labor for sugar cane
harvesting and learning the secrets to wielding political power from Tallahassee
to Washington.
The contribution amounts range from very large to small.
Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., a member of the Armed Services and Foreign Relations committees, received $80,700 from individuals, corporations and Free Cuba PAC.
Rep. Henry Bonilla, R-San Antonio, who has consistently voted against
trade with Cuba though farmers in his district have joined the Texas Farm
Bureau in lobbying
for it, received a total of $6,250.
Sen. Joe Lieberman, D-Conn., the 2000 Democratic vice presidential nominee,
received about $40,400 from both individuals and Free Cuba PAC from 1999
to
this February. He's a favorite among Cuban-Americans, who consider
him a staunch foe of communism. During the 2000 campaign, Mr. Lieberman
even visited the
grave of the late Jorge Mas Canosa, the Miami leader of the anti-Castro
movement.
Contacted by phone, spokesmen for each of the elected officials denied
that politics or contributions had anything to do with the way they voted.