Openings to Cuba
We must find a common ground.
By Jimmy Carter
A newspaper cartoon published while I was in Cuba showed me alone in
a small lifeboat in the Caribbean, surrounded by sharks. The caption was,
"I shouldn't have
asked President Bush for a ride home."
In fact, the ultimate goals of the White House and The Carter Center
are the same: to see complete freedom come to Cuba and, in the meantime,
to have friendly
relations between the people of our two nations. But the means to that
end are quite different. One approach is to continue the four-decade effort
to isolate and
punish Cuba with restricted visits and an economic embargo. The other
is for Americans to have maximum contact with Cubans, let them see clearly
the advantages
of a truly democratic society, and encourage them to bring about orderly
changes in their society.
In the United States, the two sides have become polarized, with some
well-organized and politically influential Cuban immigrants aligned with
most administrations in
Washington to oppose any substantive changes in our policy. On the
other hand, a growing number of business and agricultural leaders are joining
congressional
moderates to call for an easing of tensions and more normal relations
with the people of Cuba. This stagnant face-off has robbed our country
of a chance to achieve
our common goals.
There are indications of openness and reform in Cuba. For the first
time since the revolution 43 years ago, Cubans were permitted to hear a
clear voice calling for
freedom of speech and assembly, the organization of labor unions and
opposition political parties, free elections and the admission of human
rights and International
Red Cross inspectors. Surprisingly, and without my requesting it, the
entire text of my speech was broadcast on television and radio and printed
in Granma, the
official newspaper.
We found an unexpected degree of economic freedom. Cuban entrepreneurs
are permitted to buy agricultural produce from farm families and cooperatives,
process
the meat, vegetables and fruit and sell the finished products from
public booths. We visited one large market in Havana with 700 booths, all
doing a thriving business.
In addition, some homeowners are licensed to rent spare rooms to Cubans
or foreigners, truck owners may haul goods for hire and artisans can contract
for their
services. Although modest by our standards, these developments indicate
flexibility not previously evident.
There is little doubt that further reforms are thwarted by harsh demands
from Washington or Miami, which alienate Cubans and create the perception
that any further
moves by the Cuban government would be a sign of weakness. The dissidents
with whom we met in Cuba were unanimous in wanting to see less harsh rhetoric,
more American visitation, an end to the economic embargo on food and
medicine, and no direct or indirect financial connection between themselves
and the U.S.
government. The challenge now is to find common ground in dealing with
Cuba on which Congress, private groups and the administration can cooperate.
There are
some possibilities that would be helpful to Cuban citizens without
handing either side a political or propaganda victory. The key is to enhance
people-to-people
relationships, primarily through cultural exchanges. This would naturally
involve entertainment and sports but also science, medicine, education
and agriculture.
Cuba has a superb system of education and health. Alliances between
Cuban and American specialists in these fields could be beneficial to both
nations. Another
need is to begin quiet discussions between moderate Cuban Americans
and Cuban leaders, perhaps orchestrated by neutral parties. Both governments
would have to
ease their policies on visa permits.
Some allegations have been raised about bioterrorism. It is true that
Cuban scientists have the technical capability of producing toxins, as
do many thousands of
others in the world. The best way to answer questions and prevent any
temptation toward illicit activities is for researchers to work side by
side in laboratories and to
exchange information freely at international conferences. The wife
of Cuba's foreign minister is a renowned medical scientist who specializes
in cancer of the head and
throat. She has always been free to attend meetings concerning her
work, but her visa application was denied by the United States while we
were in Havana. It
would be helpful to curtail such restraints.
One reciprocal offer that already exists is to exchange university scholarships
for graduate students. President Bush recently proposed this opportunity
to certain
Cuban students, and President Castro has offered six years of medical
education to future doctors from the United States. Direct visits by private
citizens are also
helpful. One remarkable program is the Friendship Force, which provides
such opportunities for Americans who wish to go to Cuba. Travelers stay
in hotels for
three nights and in private homes for the rest of the week, able to
observe personally how our geographical neighbors live.
I would like to see unrestricted trade and visitation between Cuba and
the United States, as would most Americans and a strong and growing group
of Cuban
immigrants in Miami. Until this goal is politically possible, we should
take other, more modest steps toward reconciliation.
Former President Carter chairs The Carter Center in Atlanta, a nongovernmental organization working for peace and health worldwide.
© 2002