Downturn in Economy Deepens Across Mexico
Layoffs hit virtually all sectors and imperil social reforms promised by Fox.
By CHRIS KRAUL, Times Staff Writer
SAN ANDRES OCOTLAN, Mexico--From farms and automotive plants on the outskirts
of Mexico City to the industrial heartland
of Monterrey and the wineries and electronics firms in Tijuana and Guadalajara,
signs are that this nation's recession is becoming more
entrenched.
Every day, another big company or industry is hit by layoffs, the most
recent being the pivotal steel industry, where hundreds last week
received pink slips. Even the maquiladoras--the factories on the border
with the U.S. that have been jewels of Mexican economic
development--are feeling pain as never before.
Tenant farmer or textile magnate, there is no shortage of victims who could
be overwhelmed by the spreading recession. The hard
times increase fears of social unrest as well as the prospect of illegal
immigration, which could lead to more people dying in risky border
crossings. With the U.S. facing its own economic troubles, more economic
refugees won't be greeted with open arms.
The most prominent victim may be President Vicente Fox, whose ambitious
plans to transform Mexican society require a good
economy. A reform candidate whose election last year ended the 71-year
rule of the Institutional Revolutionary Party, Fox swept to
power by promising to boost prosperity, add 1.3 million new jobs in his
first year and create more social programs to address
grinding poverty and inequality.
Although still enormously popular, Fox has reason to be concerned. A failure
to deliver new jobs and prosperity will weaken him
politically and hinder efforts to carry out a bold slate of reforms ranging
from boosting the rights of indigenous peoples to overhauling
the judicial and tax systems.
The worsening times have farmers such as Rodolfo Hernandez in a bind. Corn,
carrot and lima bean prices are sinking while the
costs of diesel fuel and fertilizer are rising. All he expects to harvest
from his 25-acre farm here 40 miles southwest of Mexico City
are headaches and big losses.
"In the past, at least there was movement, equilibrium. Now, there are
no buyers at all," said Hernandez, 40.
Times have become so brutal, he said, that his younger brother Antonio,
an out-of-work tailor, illegally emigrated to Washington
state, where he quickly landed a job in construction. Rodolfo said he may
follow if things don't turn around soon. Antonio "knows
the risks, but in spite of all that he went with seven others from the
town."
Also alarmed is businessman Mayer Zaga, who has lowered prices by an average
17% on the fabrics, threads and apparel
produced by his company, Zagis SA. He said his goal is to avoid having
to lay off any of the 3,000 workers at his multimillion-dollar
firm, the country's largest yarn wholesaler.
"This is a crisis, whether we understand it or not," Zaga said as he surveyed
the gray-and-green ranks of looms on the floor of his
factory in Tepeji del Rio in Hidalgo state, 50 miles north of the capital.
Mexico dipped into recession late last year, and figures are likely to
show the nation having continued to be mired in one at least
through the second quarter of this year, which ended Saturday, according
to Ciemex/Wefa economic consultants of Philadelphia.
Mauricio Gonzalez, a director at GEA business consultants in Mexico City,
said disappointment could run deep because of
heightened expectations after Fox's election.
"Everyone was going to be happy and entertained. Now there is no party,"
he said. "People are now realizing it's not going to be
as good as they thought and that maybe [the recession] will affect them
personally."
Fox had counted on a recipe of free trade and his own businesslike efficiency
to rev up Mexico's economic performance,
generating enough income to help the government carry out sweeping new
initiatives in health coverage and education. But tax
collections have declined along with the economy, dropping an alarming
7% in May from the same month last year. The Finance
Ministry is expected to soon announce a second round of spending cuts.
Instead of all the new jobs he had promised during the grueling election
campaign, Fox has seen the loss of 200,000 jobs so far
this year--and will be lucky to end the year with as many workers as he
started with in January. Economist Rogelio Ramirez de la O
of Ecanal, a Mexico City consulting firm, thinks that the job base could
shrink by as much as 700,000. That would leave Fox 2
million jobs short of his promised 1.3 million new jobs.
"Fox will be under pressure in the coming months as the economy deteriorates
and as people present him with his promises," said
Raul Feliz, a macroeconomist at the independent Center for Economic Research
and Teaching in Mexico City.
Feliz predicts "net zero to negative" growth in new jobs and sees serious
political problems ahead. "Lower economic
development makes everything more difficult," he said.
Duration of Downturn Out of Fox's Control
It was bad news like this that finally forced Fox in mid-June to admit
for the first time that Mexico was in a recession and that he
would probably miss his economic targets.
"We need to go to the Basilica and pray to the Virgin of Guadalupe" for
a speedy economic recovery, Fox joked to reporters.
But it was a rare moment of levity. He is said by associates to be extremely
worried about the political fallout if the recession drags
on.
That the recession's duration and severity are out of his hands is adding
to Fox's frustration. The duration of the U.S. slowdown is
the determining factor because a quarter of all Mexican goods and services
is sold in the United States.
Since the U.S. recovery is an open question, so is Mexico's. The reliance
on the U.S. economy, which a few years ago shielded
Mexico's economy from foreign contagion, is now a handicap.
"Mexico was not that deeply affected by the 1997 Asian crisis because of
its U.S. exports. Today, however, the alliance with the
U.S. economy is playing the other way and Mexico has to hang on," said
Carlos Janada, a Wall Street economist specializing in
Latin America.
U.S. immigration officials also have reason to worry. If historical patterns
hold up, a prolonged Mexican recession will generate
more illegal immigration at a time when jobs are increasingly scarce on
the other side of the border, GEA's Gonzalez said.
Wayne A. Cornelius, director of the Center for Comparative Immigration
Studies at UC San Diego, said illegal immigration rose
more than 50% in the two years of Mexico's last recession, from 1994 to
1996, based on U.S. Border Patrol apprehensions.
Making matters worse for the Southern California regional economy is that
Mexican businesses along the U.S.-Mexico border
are being hit harder than those in the rest of Mexico because of the concentration
of maquiladoras, which produce goods mainly for
export to the United States.
Although there has been no measurable effect on the San Diego economy so
far, with unemployment rates holding steady, there
could be a "developing effect," said James Gerber, professor of economics
at San Diego State University and a border economics
researcher.
"I've heard of Asian manufacturers who would like to move out of Baja,
and there has been a downturn in employment in
maquiladora firms, but it's not clear what's driving that," Gerber said.
"It could be the slowdown in the United States, the overvalued
peso, the uncertainty of the Mexican tax structure or fears for the security
of foreign executives. All of that's in the mix."
Maquiladora exports are down 5% so far this year, giving rise to a unique
occurrence: layoffs in an industry that has been
accustomed to double-digit growth.
"We're seeing the first sustained drop in maquiladora jobs in 20 years,"
said Alfonso Mercado, a professor at College of Mexico
in Mexico City who studies the U.S.-Mexico border economy. "The region
might suffer a higher cost and longer [recovery] time
than other regions in Mexico, and this is new."
Japanese Firms Have Scaled Back Production
A deepening recession could mean higher unemployment, less consumption
and lower investment, whereas in previous Mexican
downturns, in 1982 and from 1994 to 1996, the Mexican border had a much
shorter crisis period than the rest of the country,
Mercado said.
Jose Ibarra, a maquiladora manager at Hitachi's television factory in Tijuana,
said most Japanese consumer electronics firms have
scaled back production in response to the U.S. slowdown. Sales of Hitachi's
line of televisions are off 45% this year. Only its
popular line of high-definition digital TVs has kept things from getting
worse.
Unlike last year, when maquiladoras were desperate for workers, Hitachi
has a six-month waiting list for job applicants, Ibarra
said.
"There aren't the jobs there used to be, especially for people who have
less than high school skills," Ibarra said. "The people
know the situation is bad."
Like their counterparts in the United States, Mexican consumers by and
large have not felt the weight of the recession. A strong
peso and wage hikes have increased individual purchasing power. This has
pushed up consumer purchases by 6.5% this year, even
as the nation's manufacturing output has declined by an estimated 3%.
But the purchases are uneven. Even as some of the poor have trouble making
ends meet, there are waiting lists for new vehicles
at imported-car dealerships in Mexico City, as more affluent consumers
try to take advantage of the strength of the peso, one of the
world's strongest currencies against the dollar this year.
The peso's strength derives in part from a massive inflow of foreign capital,
including $6.25 billion in cash that U.S. banking giant
Citigroup is paying to acquire the parent firm of Banamex, Mexico's largest
independent bank.
Economists say it's only a matter of time before the problems in Mexico's
industrial and agricultural sectors filter down to
consumers. Wage increases, easing credit and the strong peso will eventually
be negated by the effects of job losses and declining
consumer confidence.
Automotive engineer Juan Carlos Martinez of Toluca has gotten the message.
About 20% of his co-workers at the Johnson
Controls plant outside Mexico City have lost their jobs since February,
partly because of production cutbacks at DaimlerChrysler in
Toluca, a big customer.
"A year ago, it was easy to find a job. There were vacancies everywhere,"
he said. "But then came the recession and everything
froze."
Copyright 2001