Mexico targets ex-president in inquiry of 1970s murders
BY ANDRES OPPENHEIMER
MEXICO CITY -- Former President Luis Echeverría, a populist
who governed Mexico from 1970 to 1976, has emerged as the principal target
of an unprecedented
government investigation into the long-hidden ''dirty war''
waged against anti-government activists decades ago.
As if to emphasize the government's determination to punish wrongdoers,
top officials say they will invoke international treaties to overcome a
30-year statute of
limitations law that would prevent the prosecution of Echeverría
for gross human rights abuses in the 1970s.
Interior Minister Santiago Creel said the 80-year-old Echeverría
is being investigated for his alleged role in the 1968 and 1971 killings
of dozens -- perhaps hundreds --
of leftist activists, many of whom disappeared after clashes
with government forces in Mexico City demonstrations. The first incident
took place while Echeverría was
interior minister under his predecessor, the late Gustavo Díaz
Ordaz.
The Echeverría probe is among half a dozen investigations
that are putting to a test a vow by President Vicente Fox to end Mexico's
tradition of allowing powerful
politicians to get away with commiting crimes. Leaders of the
party once led by Echeverría claim Fox has embarked on a witch hunt,
and threaten to strike back with
labor union strikes and other protests if the government goes
ahead with the inquiries. ''In cases of disappearances, we will take the
position that this is a continuing
crime,'' Creel said in an interview at his office. ``There will
be a debate about this, but we believe there is a basis to make a good
argument that the statute of limitation
on these crimes has not expired.''
Echeverría, who championed Third World causes and used
to lash out against the United States during his presidency, had long been
the target of press allegations that
he had authorized the killings. But it wasn't until President
Fox's victory in 2000, when Echeverría's Institutional Revolutionary
Party (PRI) lost power after seven decades
of often authoritarian rule, that the government started a serious
investigation into the case.
Last month, the Mexican government declassified millions of government
files on the ''dirty war'' of the 70s and 80s. In addition, Fox appointed
a special prosecutor to
look into the 532 documented cases of political killings and
disappearances, including those in the 1968 clash at Mexico City's Tlatelolco
Square and the 1971 student
demonstration in the city's San Cosme district.
Until recently, Echeverría lived the privileged life of
an elder statesman of the PRI. He was a frequent visitor at the presidential
residence of Los Pinos, and
recommended loyalists to powerful jobs. One of his children,
Benito Echeverría, has headed a Mexican government tourism office
in Miami for about seven years.
MANY QUESTIONS
But, in a scene reminiscent of Chile's recent probes into former
dictator Gen. Augusto Pinochet, Echeverría was summoned by special
prosecutor Ignacio Carrillo Prieto
to testify last month and was greeted with shouts of ''assassin!''
by scores of demonstrators. The prosecutor gave the former president more
than 150 questions, which
he will have two months to answer.
Last week, Echeverría was hospitalized, suffering from
non-life-threatening respiratory infections, the health ministry said.
In a statement, the ministry said the
ex-president was admitted to Mexico City's Ignacio Chavez National
Cardiology Center on Thursday for routine tests. Echeverría's doctors
said he was no longer
suffering from fever, that his prognosis was good and that they
expected him to be out of the hospital ``in a few days.''
Government prosecutors want to know whether Echeverría
-- as many of the victims' relatives say -- ordered the repression of the
1968 student demonstration, where
army troops killed at least 30 leftist activists, while he was
interior minister. Some historians believe many more were killed in that
incident. Echeverría has said in the
past that the orders had come from President Díaz Ordaz,
and that the late president himself had publicly admitted that.
But the main charges against Echeverría focus on the June
10, 1971, killings in San Cosme by a para-military group known as ''Los
Halcones'' (The Falcons), reportedly
created by Díaz Ordaz and assigned to patrol the streets
and subway stations.
`TWO BIRDS'
Former Mexico City Mayor Alfonso Martínez Domínguez
was quoted in a 1979 interview with the weekly Proceso as saying that the
killings by the paramilitary group
``were engineered by Luis Echeverría to kill two birds
with a stone: He wanted to scare those who he said were trying to harass
his government at the very start of his
term, and he got rid of me.''
According to human rights groups, the paramilitary group not
only shot at the demonstrators, but also went to several hospitals afterwards
to kill survivors in the
emergency wards.
Echeverría declined requests for an interview, but his top attorney, Juan Velázquez, disputed the critics' version of the events.
Velázquez said the Falcons were ordered by ''somebody''
to crack down on the demonstrators with canes and, when they were met with
gunfire from the demonstrators,
went back to their headquarters to get weapons. The Falcons
did indeed go the hospitals later that day, but it was to take their own
wounded, the attorney said.
At any rate, prosecution for both the 1968 and 1971 crimes has
been proscribed, and the government will not be able to invoke international
conventions against
genocide to press charges against Echeverría, Velázquez
said.
''Assuming, without conceding, that there was a genocide, the
30 years the law would have required to file charges has already expired,''
Velázquez said. ``And
Mexico's Supreme Court ruled in 1999 that, when there is a question
of hierarchy between the Mexican Constitution and international conventions,
the Constitution
comes first.''
LATER CRIMES
Some academics concede that the Supreme Court ruling may well
protect Echeverría for these two incidents. But they add that the
former president could still be
prosecuted for later crimes, and will at any rate end his life
shrouded in controversy.
''It may be too late to do justice in connection with the events
of 1968 and 1971, but there can still be legal action regarding actions
that took place after 1973, which
have not prescribed,'' says leading historian Lorenzo Meyer.
``At any rate, forcing Echeverría to respond for his actions sets
an important precedent to prevent these
crimes from remaining unprosecuted in the future.''