Work by Famed Mexican Muralist Is Leaving L.A.
By KEITH DAVID HAMM and SUSAN BRENNEMAN, Special To The Times
A little-known Los Angeles art
treasure--a monumental mural by David Alfaro Siqueiros, one of Mexico's
most renowned and controversial artists--has
been donated to the Santa Barbara Museum of Art.
"Portrait of Present Day Mexico,"
painted nearly seven decades ago across four walls enclosing the patio
of a Pacific Palisades estate, is scheduled to go
on display at the Santa Barbara museum in December.
Siqueiros belonged to the triumvirate
of 20th century Mexican muralists known as Los Tres Grandes (the Big Three)--including
Diego Rivera and José
Clemente Orozco. The mural, a gift from Siqueiros to movie director
Dudley Murphy, is one of three the artist completed in Los Angeles during
a six-month
sojourn here in 1932. They are the only murals that Siqueiros
executed in the United States.
Fleeing house arrest in Mexico,
Siqueiros, an avowed Communist then in his 30s, finished "Portrait of Present
Day Mexico" shortly before U.S. authorities
deported him. The artwork, which depicts martyred workers and
a corrupt Mexican government, is arguably the most important of his Los
Angeles murals and
the only one to survive relatively intact.
"The mural is a wonderful gift,"
said Robert Frankel, executive director of the Santa Barbara Museum of
Art. "It's an astounding object in wonderful
condition."
"To have [a] mural of such importance
that has never been seen before put before the public is amazing," said
Luis Garza, who studied the work from
1993 to 1996 when he was the Getty Conservation Institute's
community liaison in the restoration of a Siqueiros mural at Olvera Plaza
in downtown Los
Angeles. "That mural was the front-runner of his work that followed,
a turning point. When I saw it, the pigmentation was very strong. The colors
were
vibrantly coming through."
Frankel said the mural's donors
wish to remain anonymous. However, according to the Los Angeles County
tax assessor's office, the property on Amalfi Drive has belonged to Robert
and Justine
Bloomingdale, son and daughter-in-law of Alfred and Betsy Bloomingdale,
since 1986. (Alfred was heir to the department store fortune, a founder
of Diners Club and a member of President Ronald
Reagan's "kitchen cabinet.") The Bloomingdales have declined
to comment about the mural or their gift to the museum.
Moving It Will Take 4 Months
The museum must remove the mural
from the estate and transport it to Santa Barbara. Each wall is 8 feet
tall, the longest measuring more than 30 feet. The process, which involves
a team of
conservators working with construction and transportation firms,
began the second week of August and is expected to take four months. The
work will be moved as a unit and installed at the museum just
as it was at the estate.
Museum officials would not reveal
the cost of moving the mural, nor would they disclose its current value.
However, Frankel acknowledged that it is roughly in line with an appraisal
conducted by
Christie's in 1991, when the Bloomingdales attempted to sell
the mural through the auction house.
According to Christie's public
relations manager Margaret Doyle, "Portrait of Present Day Mexico," considered
to be in mint condition, was valued between $1.5 million and $2 million.
Bidding for the work
topped out at $750,000 and it wasn't sold. At the time, Christie's
said careful studies had been done to ensure that the mural could be removed
without harm.
Frankel declined to comment on
how the Santa Barbara Museum of Art won the donation. The museum has a
nationally recognized collection of Latin American art, and in 1997 it
presented "Portrait of a
Decade," an exhibition of Siqueiros' work organized by the National
Museum of Art in Mexico City. Frankel said he learned that the mural might
be available 2½ years ago. "That's when we began a
conversation and the donors chose to work with us," he said.
According to Los Angeles County
Museum of Art spokesperson Thea Makow, LACMA officials are "delighted that
the mural is going to a public facility, especially one in Southern California,"
but did not
attempt to acquire the mural for its own collection.
Wellesley College art history
professor James Oles, who lives part time in Mexico City and co-curated
"Portrait of a Decade," said the cost of moving the mural may have dissuaded
collectors and other
museums.
"My understanding is that Christie's
could not sell it because people were reticent about [moving] it," he said.
"It's good that people will be able to see it, but it's sad that it's leaving
its original place and
leaving Los Angeles. But this mural will fit Santa Barbara's
existing collection [of Latin American art]."
Siqueiros (1896-1974), came to
Los Angeles in May 1932. Opting for exile over continued house arrest because
of his political activities, Siqueiros--a union organizer, orthodox Marxist
and member of
the Executive Committee of the Mexican Communist Party--fled
his confinement in the Mexican town of Taxco at the invitation of Mrs.
Nelbert M. Chouinard, founder of the Chouinard School of Arts (the
forerunner of CalArts).
Siqueiros chose Los Angeles because
relatives on his mother's side of the family lived here. Additionally,
Rivera and Orozco--Siqueiros' rivals--had already staked claims in other
parts of the United
States. Orozco had been working in New York while Rivera spent
time in San Francisco and then moved to fulfill a commission in Detroit.
While teaching a mural course
at Chouinard, Siqueiros and his students painted "Workers' Meeting" on
a courtyard wall at the school. A 20-by-25-foot rendition of construction
workers captivated by a
labor agitator's speech, it was unveiled in July 1932 to favorable
reviews.
Olvera Street Art Was Quickly Covered
Riding the publicity, Siqueiros
was commissioned to paint "Tropical America" on an exterior second-story
wall of the Plaza Art Center facing Olvera Street. Late into the night
before its unveiling on Oct.
9, 1932, Siqueiros labored privately on the 18-by-80-foot mural's
central composition: an imperialist eagle perched on a double cross draped
with a crucified American native. Again, Siqueiros' work
impressed critics, but many saw the piece as Communist propaganda,
and it was quickly whitewashed.
About that time, Dudley Murphy--who
had collaborated with Dadaist artist Man Ray and would later direct the
film version of the Eugene O'Neill play "Emperor Jones"--befriended Siqueiros
and invited the
artist to his Amalfi Drive estate to set up an informal, three-day
exhibition of his easel paintings.
According to an account by Murphy,
published in the Christie's auction catalog, Siqueiros sold about 10 paintings
to a "very distinguished clientele" that included actor-director Charles
Laughton and
director Josef von Sternberg. Siqueiros was so grateful that
he offered to paint a mural for Murphy, who wrote that the muralist, "his
wife Blanquita and her 8-year-old boy, whom we called 'Dinamito,'
moved in with us."
"Portrait of Present Day Mexico"
took shape over the ensuing weeks, with the painter and a few assistants
often working between midnight and 3 or 4 a.m. Painted directly onto wet
plaster in the
traditional fresco technique, the mural covers the rectangular
patio's interior walls. It was his third and final Los Angeles mural before
his deportation that November.
"Workers' Meeting" was the most
fragile of the three works. In painting it, Siqueiros experimented with
spray-painting pigments mixed with wet concrete; the murals' colors washed
away quickly.
"Tropical America," painted over for political reasons, hasn't
been readily viewable almost since it was created. It has been undergoing
on-again, off-again restoration on Olvera Street since the 1980s, a
project that is now scheduled to be completed by the spring
of 2003. The Palisades mural remains Siqueiros' best preserved and most
important Los Angeles mural.
" 'Portrait of Present Day Mexico'
is a major work in Siqueiros' artistic development," wrote art scholar
Laurance P. Hurlburt in the auction catalog essay. "It is of foremost importance
as the artist's first
use of specific contemporary political imagery."
The largest panel of the mural
shows onetime Mexican President Plutarco Elias Calles, masked and armed
with a rifle, hunkered down amid bags of money. On a short wall opposite
Calles, Siqueiros
painted New York banker J.P. Morgan, whose employee, Dwight
Morrow, served as the U.S. ambassador to Mexico during the late 1920s and
early '30s.
Between these renditions of corruption
and U.S. business interests lie martyred workers and progressives, and
opposite them on the fourth wall of the patio, a revolutionary guard. Next
to Calles on the
main wall are two impoverished women and a child--representing
the living victims of Calles' politics--in front of a pyramid.
"Siqueiros was documenting that
Mexico's politics didn't address the needs of the indigenous and the poor,"
said Patrick Davis, executive director of the Santa Barbara County Arts
Commission, which
oversees the installation of public artworks in the city. "These
themes are still an issue today. I'm assuming that this mural will stir
up some controversy [when it is displayed]."
"The important thing about any
piece of art," Frankel said, "is not whether people like it or not; it's
that they respond to it. And what [this mural] means for Santa Barbara
is exciting . . . to see a Siqueiros
mural that hasn't been damaged or deteriorated. The issue now
is if it can be moved safely. And it can be."
Keith David Hamm is a freelance writer in Los Angeles and Santa Barbara; Susan Brenneman is the Times arts editor.
Copyright 2001