Editorial: Americans in death
Immigrant Marines pay ultimate price
Bee Editorial Staff -
Among the more than 50 deaths and scores of injuries suffered
thus far by American forces in Iraq, there are many tales of heroics and
devotion to
country. But four fallen Marines deserve special mention
because they died in service to a country they could not yet call their
own. They were Pfc.
Francisco Martinez Flores, Cpl. Jose Angel Garibay and
Lance Cpl. Jesus Suarez del Solar, all born in Mexico, and Lance Cpl. Jose
Gutierrez, born in
Guatemala.
The three Mexican citizens were green card holders, and
they were in large company in the U.S. military. Some 36,000 like them
now serve in the
American armed forces. Most have green cards; others hold
some other form of legal residence. Virtually all hope one day to be American
citizens, so
much that they are willing to die for it.
Gutierrez, 27, was an orphan and an illegal immigrant who
came to California from Guatemala, on foot and by hopping trains, in 1997.
Given his legal
status, it isn't clear how he was able to join the Marines
last year. The military says it requires permanent, legal residency of
its members. But
Gutierrez was unquestionably a Marine: He died of combat
wounds on March 21. Military officials say he will be made an American
citizen
posthumously.
Immigrants have long seen the U.S. military as a gateway
to citizenship, education and economic opportunity, and the deaths of these
four Marines
echo those of other non-citizens who died for this country
before them. But their lives remind us how much we sometimes take for granted
the rights
and privileges of a citizenship they coveted. In honoring
their sacrifice, let's try not to forget how important those rights and
privileges are.