One Family Paid Dearly in 'Dirty War'
Mexico: A rebel leader's clan was targeted in army's 1970s campaign to crush guerrillas.
By JAMES F. SMITH
TIMES STAFF WRITER
ATOYAC DE ALVAREZ, Mexico -- Back in the 1970s, just bearing the name
Cabanas invited torture, disappearance and death in the villages of the
blood-splashed Sierra Madre of Guerrero state.
Lucio Cabanas Barrientos, a Mexican version of Che Guevara, was a country
teacher-turned-revolutionary leader who built up a small rebel army in
the mountains
that loom above his hometown here. He was killed Dec. 2, 1974, in an
army ambush soon after kidnapping the governor-elect of the southern state.
Nearly 30 years later, the truth is emerging about that revolt and the
army's fierce, sometimes illegal campaign to crush it. This truth contains
potentially dramatic
consequences for Mexico's modern-day transition to democracy. The nation's
"dirty war" of the '70s was divided between the countryside and the cities.
If the urban conflict was surgical, with few innocent victims on either
side, the struggle in the mountains of Guerrero state came far closer to
the Central
American-style conflicts that exploded into full-scale wars and widespread
abuses.
Within the extended Cabanas clan alone, about 100 people were taken away by security forces and never seen again, family members say.
So it is appropriate that a recent investigative session by four lawyers
for the National Human Rights Commission took place on the patio of the
simple home of Sofia
Cabanas, a cousin of Lucio.
The forms the lawyers were filling in with the testimony of townsfolk
are powerful weapons in a new Mexican war, this one against impunity, against
forgetting the
costs and lessons of past conflicts.
The evidence given here on a Saturday in early December is revealing
fresh names--names not yet listed in the commission's recently released
report about people
who disappeared in the 1970s and the first half of the '80s. It is
providing clues in the hunt for those responsible. And it is proving false
many of the official accounts
that the rights report also disavowed, claims that the disappeared
had died in armed clashes or at the hands of their own comrades.
The emerging official reports and the personal testimonies from emboldened
survivors are raising as many questions as they answer, specifically: What
happened to
the disappeared after they were taken? How did they die? Are they still
alive?
The rights commission's landmark report, issued last month, provides
case studies of 532 people believed to have been forcibly taken away in
Mexico from 1970 to
1985. Of those, 332--or nearly two-thirds--came from Guerrero. And
the vast majority of those cases occurred in the villages in and around
the sprawling
municipality of Atoyac de Alvarez, the focus of Cabanas' revolt.
In meetings here with family members of the missing, a Times reporter
heard detailed accounts of several cases that have surfaced only in recent
months and were
hurriedly added to the commission's findings.
The stories support claims by many Cabanas family members and others
in the community that the number of missing from this region is greater
than officially
acknowledged. Activists here have long claimed that more than 400 people
are missing from Atoyac alone, and about 650 from Guerrero state.
The growing list of cases adds to the already daunting task ahead for
the year-old government of Mexican President Vicente Fox as it looks into
rights abuses of the
past. Fox has pledged to appoint a special prosecutor to investigate
the disappearances.
Mexico's former government repeatedly dismissed accusations that its
forces had systematically violated human rights in the process of stamping
out the Guerrero
rebellion. But the rights commission report has provided unprecedented
details of the army's campaign in Guerrero--and of how many official lies
were told in the
past about the missing.
That the tiny villages and ranches scattered among the mountain ridges
overlooking the coastal plain of Guerrero state became breeding grounds
of rural revolt is not
surprising. Apart from the Pacific resorts of Acapulco and Zihuatanejo,
Guerrero suffers some of the worst rural poverty and some of the most repressive
local
power bosses, known as caciques, in the country.
Erasmo Cabanas Tabares remembers vividly the day--May 18, 1967--that
his distant cousin Lucio took up arms. That day, police had opened fire
on teachers and
parents demonstrating in the plaza of Atoyac, a city that now counts
about 60,000 people. Erasmo, then 13, saw the bodies of about 18 people
who died.
From his clandestine base in the mountains, Lucio Cabanas built a force of about 350 fighters. His movement was called the Party of the Poor.
Cabanas practiced his own kind of brutality, recalls retired army Maj.
Elias Alcaraz, who once pursued him. In one ambush of an army patrol in
June 1972, Cabanas'
guerrillas killed 11 soldiers. In another, in August 1974, they killed
40, Alcaraz said. He said the rebels once killed a bridegroom at his wedding
because the bride
had refused to marry one of the rebels.
"If there is ever a truth commission, let it look at the atrocities
of Lucio," Alcaraz told the newspaper Reforma. "If it was a dirty war,
it was because they dirtied it
when they started to kidnap, rob and murder."
Erasmo says his brother, Raul, and his father, Eleno Cabanas Ocampo,
disappeared on Oct. 5, 1975. They were visiting relatives in the village
of Corral Falso near
Atoyac when an army patrol arrived and forced all the men to gather
on the hamlet's basketball court.
Testimony to the rights commission from a witness identified only as
T305 says Eleno and Raul were detained that day "after having been pointed
out and for having
the name Cabanas, since it was common that they detained those with
that name even if they weren't part of the guerrillas."
The commission confirms that another brother of Erasmo's, Lucio Cabanas
Tabares, disappeared after he was snatched by soldiers from his barbershop
in Atoyac in
April 1974. In this case, the report's findings also exposed the kind
of lies typically told in the past to cover up such disappearances.
Previous accounts had said Lucio Cabanas Tabares, often confused with
his more famous cousin, had been kidnapped and presumably killed by neighboring
peasants because he had carried out robberies in the area. The commission,
researching the national security archives for the first time, found an
intelligence file that
confirmed Cabanas Tabares had been detained by the army and held in
Mexico City at Military Camp No. 1, notorious as a center for torture of
leftists. He was
never seen again.
Erasmo, now a teacher in Mexico City, was himself detained twice. His
accounts and those of survivors like him help sketch a picture of the army's
interrogation
tactics against the Guerrero revolt in those days.
After his father and two brothers disappeared, Erasmo moved to the outskirts
of Mexico City in 1976. He says he was trying to escape the conflict. He
returned
home that November to find state agents waiting. They seized him and
his cousin Antolin Cabanas, blindfolded them, and took them to what Erasmo
says was
Military Camp No. 1.
"They kicked me in the stomach and hit my ears with their open hands.
They asked for all the others who lived with me, many of them also named
Cabanas," he
recalled. "They applied electric shocks to my testicles and put my
head in dirty water until I almost drowned.
"When they took off the blindfold, I could see the room had many bloodstains," he added.
Three more Cabanas relatives living in Erasmo's house were subsequently
detained. None of the three--Margarito Castillo, Rafael Castillo and Juan
Castro--were
ever seen again, Erasmo said.
The three are confirmed as missing. They allegedly had taken part in
the kidnapping that November of businessman Enrique Pineda Cuevas. Pineda
was later
rescued.
Erasmo was released after two weeks, but a year later he was grabbed
again and tortured anew, he says. The treatment this time included a novelty:
His tormentors
forced chile-laced mineral water up his nose.
Erasmo was among more than 40 people who traveled recently to Sofia
Cabanas' home in Atoyac to offer testimony to the rights commission as
it moves on to the
next phase of its probe.
"Even though we listen to the testimony with sadness, we are happy to
see the people losing their fear and speaking out as they haven't done
for years," he said.
"Now that there is this opening up, we need to take advantage of it."
In Atoyac, the oldest of the villagers, gray-haired and stooped, trudged
forward with their faded memories. They clutched pictures, from tiny ID
photos to life-size
portraits, to prove their missing relatives were once real and vital.
Under the shade of a mango tree, the commission lawyers listened patiently
to their stories. Some witnesses had testified many times before, but others
were
appearing for the first time. Skillfully, the lawyers picked up on
what was new and probed for details.
After one man described how his brother had disappeared in 1974, he
went on to tell about his own brief detention in a military barracks in
1970. Lawyer Jose Luis
Espetia pressed him: "Who else did you see in detention? It is very
important to remember. Who held you? Were you mistreated?"
The man recalled several names, to be cross-checked later against lists
of the known missing and of suspected rights abusers. Importantly, the
witness, Agustin
Barrientos Flores, said he had never testified before, so this was
fresh information. Espetia gave him a telephone number to call in case
he should remember more.
Many witnesses, such as 84-year-old Romana Bello Cabanas, can neither
read nor write, and put an inked fingerprint over their names. Bello's
story illustrates how
the disappearances spread anguish like ripples from a stone thrown
into still water:
Her son, Carmelo Juarez Bello, was rounded up in the village of Ticui
in September 1974, accused of being a guerrilla. He was 26, the father
of four children. When
he vanished, his wife couldn't cope. She abandoned the children to
her mother-in-law. Bello then struggled to raise her grandchildren on her
own.
One of those children, Adolfo Juarez, is now 28. He was just a year old when his father disappeared.
"This was covered up for a very long time. Too many innocent people were taken away. Too many children grew up without fathers," Juarez said.
Some families suffered multiple disappearances.
Rosa Castro Velazquez, 72, said her brother Isaias disappeared in 1972.
That same year, her husband, Alejandro Arroyo Cabanas, was taken away and
tortured.
Their village near Atoyac, San Vicente de Benitez, was besieged; army
tanks parked in front of her house and soldiers dug trenches across the
road.
When her husband was released from jail after six weeks, "he had to drag himself to us," she said, because he had been tortured.
Estela Arroyo, 37, said her father "came out of jail, but he came out
dead. He went into trances, he blacked out. He constantly relived the tortures
and the humiliation
he suffered at the hands of the army."
Arroyo recalled her father's account of the worst torture--confinement
in a steel drum so hot that it burned his skin. To his dying day in 1994,
she said, he needed
special care.
Arroyo said he once told her the reason for the torture.
"They told him to abandon his second name because they were going to
finish off all the Cabanas," she said. "He refused. He kept telling them,
'My name is
Alejandro Arroyo Cabanas.' "
(BEGIN TEXT OF INFOBOX / INFOGRAPHIC)
Rebels of the 'Dirty War'
Organization: Partido de los Pobres (Party of the Poor)
Founded: 1967 by Lucio Cabanas Barrientos (killed 1974)
Membership: About 350
Ideology: Socialist-agrarian
Where active: Guerrero and Aguascalientes states, Mexico City
Noted actions: 1974 kidnapping of Guerrero Gov.-elect Ruben Figueroa
For information about reprinting this article, go to http://www.lats.com/rights