The ruins of another US try at democracy: Haiti
By Nick Caistor
LONDON - The United States is committed to building democracies in Afghan-istan
and Iraq. But there is a country much closer to home
that is in desperate need of help - a country where the US and the international
community have left a job half done and have abandoned
millions of innocent citizens to poverty and despair.
That country is Haiti. Back in 1994, Bill Clinton and the Organization
of American States (OAS) called the bluff of a nasty military
dictatorship there. After a brief showdown, they succeeded in restoring
to power the elected president Jean-Bertrand Aristide, a Catholic
priest whose populist Creole rhetoric captured the hearts of the poor masses.
The United Nations came in to help create an independent
judiciary and a new police force, and to lay the basis for continued democratic
rule.
Ever since, Mr. Aristide - who, along the way, resigned his priesthood
and lost much of his popularity - or his associates have held power.
But Haiti is poorer than ever, and the political situation has shown little
or no improvement. During the months they were in the country,
American troops helped build a few schools and a few roads, but then pulled
out, anxious not to be seen as an occupying power.
The UN stayed much longer. Its compound at the international airport in
the Haitian capital, Port-au-Prince, received plane loads of aid, as
well as small numbers of troops and larger numbers of international experts
in judicial reform, police training, and human rights. But
because of allegations that Aristide's election to his second presidency
in late 2000 was rigged, the UN pulled out of Haiti completely the
day before he took office in February 2001. Secretary-General Kofi Annan
criticized the continuing instability in the country, and warned
that Haiti could become an international "pariah" if the situation continued.
And pariah it has become.
International agencies and many individual countries have refused to send
aid or enter into financial deals with the Aristide government. The
opposition is so fragmented it can only agree on the "illegality" of the
Aristide administration and complain of repeated attacks by Aristide
thugs or other government attempts to disrupt democratic rights.
Aristide - who grew to fame promoting the rights of the poor through rabble-rousing
liberation theology - has seen a dramatic erosion of his
charismatic appeal to many ordinary Haitians. They have seen him keep few
of his promises over the past decade and find themselves
even poorer and more desperate than ever. The president now rarely appears
in public, staying enclosed behind the high walls of his estate
in the Port-au-Prince neighborhood of Tabarre, earning himself the nickname
"baron of Tabarre."
This summer, Aristide announced that voodoo, the animistic belief practiced
throughout rural Haiti, would be recognized as an official
religion alongside Roman Cath-olicism and Pro-testant faiths. Haitian critics
of his rule argue that this shows how desperate he has
become in his efforts to find support ahead of legislative elections, due
at the end of the year or early in 2004. These critics also recall the
way the Duvalier dictatorship coopted voodoo beliefs to fan public fears
and used the tontons macoute (gangs of thugs) to terrorize the
populace. And they suggest that today's criminal groups - the chimères
- that operate at night in rural areas are simply this government's
version of the tontons macoute.
Opposition groups in Haiti are refusing to participate in the coming elections.
They claim they'll be rigged by the government, and they don't
want to give Aristide further legitimacy. The OAS is starting from scratch,
hurriedly trying to set up an electoral commission that all sides
can agree will impartially guarantee free and fair elections.
The Bush administration could and should make a vital difference. The White
House could put pressure on the Aristide regime to guarantee
the rights of the opposition parties to organize and campaign without fear.
It could also pressure the opposition to end its three-year
boycott of the government and convince them that the play of political
forces can bring progress to all Haitians.
If the US continues to look the other way, Haiti's future is grim. With
no genuine political participation, democratic practice - never truly
established since the fall of the Duvaliers 17 years ago - will wither
more. The only people who will find comfort in that are the more extreme
elements in the Aristide entourage, the drug bosses who thrive in any "failed
state" of the Caribbean and Latin America, and the
boat-builders who will be rubbing their hands, anticipating increased business
from compatriots fleeing across the sea to the US.
• Nick Caistor is a British journalist who recently visited Haiti for the BBC World Service.