BY FRANK DAVIES
WASHINGTON -- Under fire but ever resilient, Janet Reno once again
is
defending a controversial law enforcement action, the latest
crisis to punctuate
a remarkable seven-year tenure as attorney general.
Some Capitol Hill critics and legal commentators are offering
harsh critiques
of the predawn raid to seize Elian Gonzalez, while other analysts
and former
colleagues say she will weather this latest controversy the way
she has Waco,
independent counsel disputes, spy flaps and many tough legal
decisions, with
equanimity and consistency.
Reno said Monday she had ''no regrets whatsoever'' about the raid
in Little
Havana Saturday to seize the boy and reunite him with his father.
''I tried my level best to make sure we avoided this situation
and if I bent over
backward, so be it,'' she said on NBC's Today. ''I'm satisfied
with the result.''
Then the attorney general left for the White House and an event
she attends every
year, the Easter egg roll mobbed by children. As before, she
read to kids from
Voyage to the Bunny Planet, about a benevolent rabbit who has
a terrible day and
seeks solace in a kinder, more peaceful world.
She wont find solace on Capitol Hill today, when she plans to
meet with several
senators, including Majority Leader Trent Lott, who denounced
the raid. Monday,
House Judiciary Chairman Henry Hyde said he would launch ''a
preliminary
inquiry'' into the incident.
SPEAKER 'APPALLED'
Hyde said he was acting at the request of House Speaker Dennis
Hastert, who
said he was ''appalled'' by the seizure of the boy.
This is nothing new for Reno. She has faced a series of tough
calls since taking
office in 1993, when she approved the FBI assault on Waco in
one of her first
decisions.
''I cant think of an attorney general who has been on the hot
seat so many times,''
said Stanley Brand, a veteran Washington defense lawyer. ''For
starters, she
appointed more independent counsels than anyone [seven] -- and
got criticized
when she didn't appoint more.''
One legal commentator who has defended Reno and the administration
during
impeachment said he was troubled by the raid, and that the attorney
generals
tenure, the longest since 1829, will be known by the bookends
of Waco and
Little Havana.
''The raid was precipitous, and looks retaliatory, like she got
mad at the 11th
Circuit ruling'' that kept Elian in the United States, said Paul
Rothstein, a
Georgetown University law professor.
''Its very harmful to her record.''
That criticism differs from those who say she is too cautious,
that she took too
long to decide on independent counsels in campaign-finance cases,
and then
decided against an independent probe of practices by President
Clinton and Vice
President Gore.
She was also criticized for refusing an FBI request for a wiretap
in the probe of
possible Chinese spying at a nuclear weapons lab.
'OVERLY PRUDENT'
''She is very reluctant to reach decisions and take action,''
said Stanley Renshon,
a political psychologist at City University of New York. ''So
in the end she gets
second-guessed more and takes a lot more heat. She has a pattern
of being
overly prudent.''
But Brand said he would rate Reno as ''very effective,'' someone
who gave ''a
human face'' to law enforcement and established a reputation
of independence
and integrity that served her well during various Clinton scandals.
''She does her own thing, and political attacks don't stick --
the public knows she
is no crony of Clinton,'' Brand said.
Shay Bilchik, who headed juvenile justice programs for six years
under Reno,
said that her careful deliberation may be misinterpreted as undue
caution.
''For an important decision she goes through a thorough, inclusive
process,'' said
Bilchik, who also worked for Reno when she was Miami-Dade state
attorney.
''And she does it with a lot of intestinal fortitude.''
Walter Dellinger, who served as acting solicitor general under
Reno, told
American Lawyer, a legal journal: ''Often the Washington establishment
failed to
understand Janet's greatest strength, which is that she doesn't
give a damn what
they think.''
Several political observers have noted that repeatedly, from the
handling of Waco
evidence to the nuclear weapons case, calls for her resignation
or new
investigations have faded. In the last three years, Reno has
testified before
Congress at least 21 times.
Copyright 2000 Miami Herald