Associated Press
Text of letter, dated Monday, sent to Attorney General Janet Reno
and Doris
Meissner, commissioner of the Immigration and Naturalization
Service, from
pediatrician Dr. Irwin Redlener. He is professor of pediatrics
at Albert Einstein
College of Medicine, and president and director of community
pediatrics at the
Children's Hospital at Montefiore in New York.
At the request of Commissioner Meissner, I have been actively
engaged in
providing strategic guidance regarding management of the Elian
Gonzalez case,
including the selection of the mental health professional team.
This team was
charged with establishing guidelines to ensure an orderly and
positive transfer of
the child to the custody of his father.
I believe this nationally esteemed team of child mental health
professionals has
been highly effective in providing the needed guidance. As requested,
the team
focused on recommendations specifically geared toward what the
adults related
to Elian should do in order to ensure the best possible environment
for the child's
reunification with his father. From the beginning, there was
an explicit, prospective
agreement that the mental health team would meet with the father
and with the
custodial family in Miami and not meet directly with the little
boy. This was
because the team was asked to evaluate not whether the transfer
was being
made, but how it would be made in the least traumatic way possible.
In recent days the crisis has taken a profound turn for the worse.
There are
continued, frantic legal maneuverings of the Miami family, a
bevy of new,
unfounded allegations of paternal abuse raised by the custodial
family about the
father's former relationship with Elian and the release of a
videotape showing this
6-year-old boy expressing anger and other most unusual behaviors
on what
appeared to be a coached, homemade recording. All of this has
significantly
raised the stakes and our level of concern about Elian's immediate
well-being,
particularly since it is occurring in an environment of radical
hysteria, and
suggestions of public defiance and potential violence promulgated
by the
custodial family and their supporters in Miami.
My point is this: Elian Gonzalez is now in a state of imminent
danger to his
physical and emotional well-being in a home that I consider to
be psychologically
abusive. In a less politically charged environment, out of the
limelight of what has
become a media frenzy, appropriate child welfare workers and
other public
officials would have already been called upon to evaluate the
safety of the current
environment and, in my view, would have removed Elian from the
custody of the
Lazaro Gonzalez.
Therefore, in my professional judgment, the United States government,
through its
appropriate agencies and under its legally vested rights and
responsibilities,
should:
1. Immediately remove Elian Gonzalez from the custody of Lazaro
Gonzalez. As I
indicated above, the current environment and the production of
the videotape last
week reflect a profoundly disturbing and dangerous environment
for this child.
2. Return Elian to the custody of his biologic father, Juan Miguel
Gonzalez, as
quickly as possible. Every day, indeed every hour of delay in
this inevitable and
appropriate reunification is harmful to the boy and is the cause
of extreme
anguish to a legitimately distressed father. Our country has
no reason and no
right to continue this unconscionable refutation of a parent's
moral right to be with
his child.
3. Ask the custodial family to participate in discussions around
implementation of
reunification recommendations made by your own mental health
consulting team.
This should happen once Elian is returned to the custody of his
father.
I believe there is no justification whatsoever to wait any longer
in carrying out
these actions that I believe are legally appropriate and, more
importantly, clearly
in the best interest of this child who continues to be horrendously
exploited in this
bizarre and destructive ambiance. It has gone on far too long.
Copyright 2000 Miami Herald