BY AMY DRISCOLL
Attorney General Janet Reno's decision Friday to bring in a team
of independent
psychiatrists and psychologists to help guide Elian's reunion
with his father
mirrors a common practice followed in courts across the country.
In divorce cases, child-custody disputes, abuse and dependency
hearings --
where acrimony can overwhelm the best interests of a child --
judges routinely
use psychological evaluations as a tool to help families work
out their problems
with minimal trauma.
And in a case such as Elian's, which one expert likened to ``a
really nasty divorce
case,'' an independent voice representing the child's best interests
can smooth
the way between warring factions of the same clan.
RECOMMENDATIONS
In Miami-Dade, the court evaluation unit employs psychologists
to offer
independent recommendations to judges who must decide custody
in cases that
can include abuse and neglect.
``We work in the best interests of the child, first and foremost,''
said clinical
director Tracey Ziegler. ``The child's needs come first.''
A case such as Elian's would require about two weeks' time and
the involvement
of the entire family, she said.
``I would do an observation of the boy with the various members
of the family -- his
father, the Miami cousins -- to watch the dynamics and interactions.
I'd watch to
see the level of comfort on the part of the child, and how attuned
the adults are to
the needs of the child,'' she said. ``Do they put the child's
needs before their
own?''
Her recommendation would depend partly on the strength of the
prior bond
between father and son. ``It depends upon the relationship of
the child and
parent,'' she said. ``If the father can provide a safe and loving
environment, and the
parental bond is there, those are factors I would take into consideration.''
AD LITEM PROGRAM
In Broward County, family law coordinator Heidi DiCicco oversees
the guardian ad
litem program, where volunteers go to court on behalf of children
in divorce or
custody cases.
``In my experience, children do suffer from separation from a
parent in a custody
or other dispute,'' she said. ``The parental bond is very important.''
Judges rarely ask young children to choose between sides of the
family. ``A child
torn between parents will want to please both,'' DiCicco said.
``Asking that
question in an interview setting is just not a good idea.''
Experts say the parent in a case such as Elian's also would have
to provide a
combination of nurturing and structure to meet the emotional
needs of a child who
has been traumatized by the loss of his mother.
``It's very hard and confusing for a child that age, especially
because we don't
really know all that has been said to him by the family in the
U.S.,'' said Judith
Becker Bryant, a psychology professor at the University of South
Florida,
specializing in child psychology.
``It's kind of analogous to a really nasty divorce case,'' she
said, ``with one parent
trying to keep the child from the other. . . . I imagine this
is one confused little
boy. He's getting so many mixed messages about who is a good
guy and who is
a bad guy. That's a terrible position to put a little kid in.''
After four months apart from Elian, she said, the father will
have to pay close
attention to the cues of his child during any reunion.
``Hopefully, his father will know him well enough to know when
to step back, when
to give him a little time and space,'' she said. ``A good, sensitive
parent should be
able to sense that with his child. Of course, that depends on
the relationship they
had previously.''
Copyright 2000 Miami Herald