Battle over Elian to resume in Atlanta court
The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will hear brief arguments on a claim
by
Elian's Miami relatives that the 6-year-old should be allowed to pursue
political
asylum in the United States because he would be persecuted if he returns
to
communist-ruled Cuba.
Elian's father, Juan Miguel Gonzalez, was reunited with his son after federal
agents
seized him from the Miami kinfolk in a predawn raid on April 22. Juan Gonzalez
has
asked the court to drop the asylum petition so he can take Elian back to
their
hometown of Cardenas, Cuba.
"It appears that the court is going in the direction of allowing the Miami
relatives to
pursue the asylum claim in spite of the wishes of his father," said Dale
Schwartz, an
Atlanta immigration lawyer and a former president of the American Immigration
Lawyers Association.
Donato Dalrymple, one of the two men who rescued Elian, filed a petition
with the
11th Circuit Court of Appeals requesting that Kendall Coffey be replaced
as an
attorney representing Elian's interests.
"I'm just doing all that I can do to be able to rescue Elian again," Dalrymple said.
Dalrymple said he took the action because Coffey said he would not argue
the case
about the government raid on the Miami home of Elian's great-uncle, Lazaro
Gonzalez.
Rallies in New Jersey, Washington
Elian has been at the center of a custody battle since he was rescued off
the
Florida coast on November 25 after floating on an inner tube for 50 hours.
His
mother and 10 others died when their small boat sank as they tried to make
it
from Cuba to the United States. The boy and two adults survived.
A group of women gathered outside the Justice Department in Washington
to
honor Elian's mother and to mark International Mothers Day.
"We must be her voice," said one woman speaking at the rally.
Elian was put in the temporary custody of great-uncle Lazaro Gonzalez in
Miami.
He quickly became a poster boy on both sides of the Florida Straits --
to exiles in
Florida, he is a symbolic victim of Cuban President Fidel Castro's revolution;
to
Castro, he is a pawn of the Miami exile "Mafia" and U.S. hard-line policy
toward
the island.
Lazaro Gonzalez and Fidel Castro's estranged daughter, Alina Fernandez,
spoke
at a rally on Wednesday in Liberty State Park in Jersey City, New Jersey,
near
the Statue of Liberty. They spoke to dozens of Cuban exiles opposed to
Elian's
return to Cuba.
Father's arrival in U.S. changes court fight
When Juan Gonzalez, a Cuban tourism worker, flew to Washington, D.C., on
April 6 to reclaim his son, he changed the nature of the legal battle.
Through
his lawyer, he accused his uncle Lazaro of trying to destroy his family
and asked
the court to dismiss Lazaro Gonzalez's petition requesting political asylum
for Elian.
"The dynamics of the case make the position of the father vis-a-vis Elian
unavoidable. It has to be addressed by the court," University of Miami
law
professor Bernard Perlmutter said. "Just the fact that Elian has been restored
to
the care of his father would make it very difficult for the court to render
a
decision that would rend asunder this family a second time."
Elian has been staying with his father, stepmother Nercy and baby half-brother
Hianny at the Wye River Plantation, a secluded conference center on Maryland's
Eastern shore. He is under court order not to leave the country while his
appeal
is pending.
Neither the boy nor his father are expected to attend the Atlanta hearing
Thursday. The Miami relatives, including Lazaro Gonzalez and his daughter
Marisleysis, who helped care for Elian, have said they plan to travel to
Atlanta.
Meanwhile, a court-ordered psychiatric evaluation of Elian to be used in
consideration of his appeal was filed with the court on Wednesday. But
the panel
sealed the contents so they will not be made public.
The report is based on the observations of psychiatrist Paulina Kernberg
and
clinical social worker Susan Ley.
Ruling may hinge on definition of 'any alien'
Legal experts say the 11th Circuit's decision will hinge on its interpretation
of a
statute that says "any alien" may apply for political asylum. The question
is
whether Congress, when it established the law, envisioned that a 6-year-old
would seek refuge.
Even if Elian gets a hearing, it would be held before an asylum officer
for the
U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service. The INS previously ruled the
boy
belongs with his father.
And even if Elian is awarded political asylum, there would be little to
prevent
Juan Gonzalez from returning to Cuba with his son.
"There's nothing in the law that says that if you're offered political
asylum, you
have to accept," Perlmutter said. "There would be nothing, except perhaps
an
order from the INS, that would prevent the father from taking him by his
hand
and returning him to Cardenas, Cuba."
The Associated Press and Reuters contributed to this report.