Fuel price concessions end deadly protests in Ecuador
BY JIM WYSS
Special to The Herald
QUITO, Ecuador -- After 10 days of civil disorder and the deaths
of three Indian
protesters, President Gustavo Noboa reached an accord Wednesday
with
indigenous leaders that promises an end to demonstrations but
could alienate the
country's business elite.
Under the 24-point deal, the government agreed to reduce heavily
subsidized
cooking gas prices 20 percent to $1.60 per canister and freeze
gasoline and
diesel prices until year's end.
In addition, the administration will release the dozens jailed
during the strikes and
compensate the families of those that were hurt and killed by
the police. In
exchange, the thousands of indigenous protesters who have been
camped out at
a local university since last week agreed to go home, ending
a potentially bloody
confrontation.
'VICTORY FOR ALL'
``This agreement is a victory for everybody, not just the indigenous
population,''
said march leader Antonio Vargas, president of the country's
largest indigenous
organization, CONAIE.
Victory or not, analysts are hoping the deal will end one of the
most violent
protests the country has seen in years.
Haunted by the ghosts of the indigenous-led coup of 1999 that
toppled President
Jamil Mahuad and shoved the mild-mannered Noboa into the nation's
top spot,
the administration took an unusually tough stance against protesters.
Initially, it refused to even consider price revisions. Then,
when protesters broke
off talks Friday, Noboa issued an emergency decree that allowed
him to use the
army to break up meetings and raid the buildings that protesters
had turned into
their headquarters and barracks.
The violence came to a head Monday when the army and a mob clashed
over
control of a bridge in the jungle town of Tena. By the time it
was over, three
people had been killed, including a minor, and dozens were injured.
FLIGHTS HAMPERED
Protesters also burned down the town's air traffic control tower
to keep more
troops from being flown in. In a separate incident, a demonstrator
was shot dead
in Tungurahua province.
Hoping to defuse the situation and avert a national strike that
labor unions had
announced for Wednesday, the administration resumed talks late
Tuesday.
Political analyst Simon Pachano, director of the Latin American
Faculty of Social
Sciences, said the demonstrations turned violent because neither
side was willing
to compromise.
``The government thought they could solve the problem with a strong-arm
approach, and they found out they couldn't,'' Pachano said.
As a result, he said, the administration has come out looking
mean-spirited and
weak. On the other hand, the indigenous movement -- which had
been in decline
since its aborted 1999 coup attempt -- was given new life.
BUSINESS BACKLASH
``Many of the country's powerful groups are going to be angry
over these
concessions,'' said Gustavo Arteta, an analyst at the Social
Development Corp.,
an economic think tank. ``Their attitude will basically be that
the government
wants to raise their taxes but isn't willing to cut subsidies.''
The government has been trying to make fiscal ends meet to unblock
a $304
million loan from the International Monetary Fund. Wednesday's
agreement will
create a fresh $20 million to $30 million budget gap that the
government will have
to cover one way or another, Arteta said.
Since 1997, Ecuador has had five presidents, two constitutions
and multiple
cabinet changes. By reaching an agreement with the protesters,
Noboa has
apparently survived the first true threat to his presidency,
but his popularity is
slipping.