Gulf widens between Cuba's haves and have-nots
By Stephanie Shapiro
HAVANA, Cuba - The gaunt bicycle taxi driver in ragged clothes who
wheeled a travel companion and me over Havana's pocked side streets
said he earned $7 a month plus tips and could not afford shoes for his
daughter.
He would move to the United States if he could. But he didn't blame Fidel
Castro, whom he still revered. How could the leader give to his people,
he asked, if he has nothing to give?
Patriotism and acute need make strange bedfellows, but for many
Cubans, it's all of a piece. Such paradoxes seem to define life in the
island
nation.
Not everyone in Cuba is pro-Castro, of course. His sweeping crackdown
on dissidents occurred largely during our stay.
But Cubans of all stripes can point to any number of reasons for their
hardships - the U.S. trade embargo, a faltering economy and their
government's archaic restrictions. At this point in the convoluted history
of
Cuban-American relations, no one cause and no one government can be
singled out for blame. They are of a piece as well.
And whether they side with Mr. Castro or with the dissidents he threw in
jail, average Cubans have a more pressing concern than ideology: survival.
When the dollar was made legal tender along with the peso by Mr. Castro
in 1993 after the collapse of the Soviet bloc, he helped to create a class
system as a crutch for limping socialism - yet another mind-bending twist.
As our van driver intoned with a mock air of sage wisdom: "Dollars are
the hope of the world."
Those who have access to U.S. dollars, through work in the tourism
industry or the largesse of exile family members, are at the top of the
ladder. The U.S. government recently increased the amount of cash
travelers are allowed to carry to friends and family in Cuba even as it
severely curtailed educational tours to the country. Such contradictory
moves send mixed messages while widening the gulf between Cuba's
haves and have-nots.
Clearly, the striking woman who alighted from a car at the trendy El Aljibe
restaurant in Havana was living a dollar-enhanced life that most Cubans
can only imagine. Dressed all in white, she made a dramatic entrance,
air-kissing friends and staff with movie-star élan.
In Old Havana, we visited a crowded "dollar store," where those with
dollars buy electronics, washing machines and Cokes at prices above
those in the United States.
But most Cubans we met were not profiting from policy loopholes. In
Havana, we also saw Cubans waiting patiently in long lines to receive
monthly rations of meat, flour and other staples. Our bicycle taxi driver
told us these provisions often ran out before his appointed time to collect
them.
While Cuba trades with other countries and the United States has relaxed
the embargo to permit the sale of food and medicines to the country, it
still
lacks necessities. As a result, everyone, it seemed, has honed a strategy
for asking, whether for money or books or toothpaste.
For example, we encountered ingratiating sorts on the street who offered
guidance - for a price. When I took a photo of a young man carrying a
spectacular cake, he automatically asked for a dollar. When we snapped
leap-frogging children, adults demanded candy for them.
In more official settings, asking took on a genteel guise. Students at
an arts
school performed for visitors who came with donations, including art
materials, guitar strings, a violin and cash. At an AIDS clinic in Matanzas,
the grateful staff reminded us of all that their American benefactors had
done for them. The need for more assistance was implicit.
In Havana, the vice president of a synagogue said she spent much of her
time soliciting everything from matzo to medical supplies from Jewish
communities around the world.
My travel companion's mugging in a desolate Havana neighborhood
summed up Cuba's plight. A boy, perhaps 13, had tried to snatch her
money belt. He failed, but she was badly bruised and scraped.
At a hospital, she received immediate attention. The visit was free, of
course.
But it took stops at two pharmacies to fill prescriptions for an antibiotic
and ibuprofen. Even with its own biotechnology industry, Cuba still suffers
from shortfalls of basic drugs.
The next day, as we waited for a cab, a man idling on a corner befriended
us and asked my friend about her injuries. His concern seemed genuine.
But when we got into a cab, he hopped in, too. He insisted on staying
with us to make sure there would be no more trouble. It wouldn't cost
much, he said.
When we declined his offer, he shrugged and exited the cab. It was worth
a try.
Such constant asking must take a toll on the collective soul of Cubans.
As
neighbors of the United States, they are also reminded ad nauseam of
Americans' voracious consumption of the luxuries they are denied by the
embargo.
After years of this, an ever-present sense of deprivation has set in,
determining Cubans' national character as much as socialism.
Again, it's all of a piece.
Stephanie Shapiro is a reporter for The Sun.
Copyright © 2003