After a century, Guantánamo still 'a nice option'
BY CAROL ROSENBERG
GUANTANAMO BAY NAVAL BASE, Cuba -- Until its latest incarnation as an offshore
internment center for
international terror suspects, this U.S. Navy base in southeast Cuba could
be summed up in a slogan:
Last American outpost on communist soil.
A model of post-Cold War downsizing, it was in virtual ''caretaker status,''
says the base commander,
Navy Capt. Bob Buehn, who has seen the number of U.S. military personnel
triple since Christmas.
U.S. troops first arrived on this site in 1903, leasing it as a ''coaling
station,'' or refueling port, with a
more friendly, if not subservient, Cuban government.
A century later, it is still ''a nice option to have,'' a strategic slice
of offshore, extra-judicial territory
where in 1994 and 1995 the United States housed some 50,000 Haitians and
Cubans captured at sea,
says Kevin Whitaker, a U.S. diplomat on the State Department's Cuba Desk.
''It gives the decision-makers flexibility,'' he says.
For example, at any given time since the late 1990s, the State Department
and Immigration and
Naturalization Service have used the base to house a revolving population
of about 40 Cubans and
Haitians -- people found at sea who have credible fear of persecution if
they are returned home. To
discourage a widespread exodus, the Clinton administration established
a policy of housing asylum
seekers at Guantánamo until a third country, not the United States,
agreed to give them safe haven.
Before the latest arrival of terror suspects, it was hard to spot anyone
in uniform among the 2,400
inhabitants. Years of Pentagon out-sourcing meant that an estimated 1,100
contract laborers were
more likely to swab the decks and serve the grub than the 700 sailors and
Marines living on the base at
any given time.
Filipinos, for example, run the ferry that links two sides of the base
across Guantánamo Bay. Jamaicans
change sheets at the bachelor officers' quarters and serve ribs and beer
at The Jerk House, an outdoor
eatery alongside the Officers' Club.
The few Americans around the sprawling 45-square-mile base live mostly
in suburban-style housing.
Sailors' spouses and their children occupy themselves with the schools,
churches and open-air Lyceum
cinema that to this day gives the base the feel of small-town America,
circa 1950 -- even with al Qaeda
and Taliban prisoners over the hill at Camp X-Ray.
There are two 50-member platoons of Marines to patrol 17.4 miles of barbed-wire-topped
fence-line.
They also sit with M-16 assault rifles in 15 watchtowers, monitoring members
of Fidel Castro's Frontier
Brigade, arrayed in their own towers at distances of 300 to 1,500 yards
away.
''We watch them. They watch us,'' says Marine Maj. Scott Packard, who before
the prison project arrived
was the highest-ranking Marine on the base. ``We enjoy a pretty much benign
relationship with the
Cubans on the fence-line.''
So much so that the major says the last time a Marine fired his weapon
in the Cuban direction was in
1972 -- decades before Jack Nicholson growled, ''You can't handle the truth,''
as a grizzled Marine
general commanding Guantánamo in the Tom Cruise-Demi Moore Hollywood
hit, A Few Good Men.
But the truth is, it's a pretty boring business compared to the height
of the Cold War when Washington
maintained artillery, tank and air units at Guantánamo to check
Soviet ambitions. Now U.S. and Cuban
troops on watch around the clock are mostly on alert for Cubans trying
to reach the U.S. base through
a Cuban minefield, says Packard, adding it happens a couple times a year.
So why stay here?
Coast Guard Lt. Cmdr. Brendan McPherson says Guantánamo's strategic
value is the same today as it
was 100 years ago -- as a sheltered harbor off the Windward Passage, a
Caribbean choke point
between Cuba, Jamaica and Haiti. Until the terror project came ashore,
in fact, Coast Guard spotter
aircraft and cutters were among the most frequent visitors, stopping to
refuel from patrols in search of
drug smugglers and migrants trying to sneak into South Florida by raft
or pleasure boat.
During the Clinton administration it was also a diplomatic carrot to the
Castro government. In
statements not since echoed by the Bush administration, according to Whitaker,
the Democrats said a
negotiated withdrawal from the bay could be part of a successful transition
to democracy in Havana.
Meantime, the Americans are staying rent-free. Under a 1934 lease agreement,
the U.S. is to pay the
Cuban government $2,000 a year in gold for the base. That works out today
to $4,085, according to
U.S. estimates.
But the Cubans no longer cash the check, a reflection of Castro's policy
of denying the legitimacy of the
pact that gave the U.S. government a sovereign slice of Cuba.
Even so, U.S. commanders say they take seriously a statement by Raul Castro,
commander of the
Cuban armed forces and brother of Fidel, that he would return to them any
prisoner who might break
free of Camp X-Ray and manage to maneuver through either the shark-infested
waters or minefields.
And base commander Buehn says he likewise took seriously, but did not need
to accept, a Cuban offer
to send doctors to assist in the prisoners' medical care.