Argentine Jews ask Israel for help in recovering bodies from 'dirty war'
JERUSALEM (AP) -- Jewish dissidents in Argentina endured especially cruel
treatment in that country's "dirty war," their families said Monday as
they called on
Israel to fulfill a moral obligation to help recover bodies of the "disappeared."
An Israeli minister recently claimed that the new Argentine president has
pledged to
track down the bodies of Jews who disappeared during the 1976-83 military
dictatorship, although President Fernando de la Rua has since said his
offer was
misunderstood.
One victim's brother, Oskar Jaimovich, told the parliament's immigration
committee that anti-Semitism played a role in the torture and execution
of his
17-year-old sister, Alejandra, by paramilitary forces over the summer of
1976.
"It is expected that the Israeli government represents Jews and should
deal
with such problems -- to check what role anti-Semitism played and why
Jews were treated worse," Jaimovich said.
During the "dirty war," at least 9,000 leftists and dissidents vanished
after
being detained by the junta's security forces, according to an Argentine
government report. Human rights groups say the figure is closer to 30,000.
Of those who vanished, up to some 2,000 were Jewish, said Diaspora
Affairs Minister Michael Melchior, although Argentinean Jewish groups
estimate the number to be approximately 1,500.
Melchior told the committee that he did not understand why de la Rua
backtracked on his commitment last month to track down the bodies of
missing Jews so their families could bury them according to Jewish ritual.
After Melchior told reporters about the alleged offer, the Argentine
government issued a statement saying Melchior's account of his meeting
with
the president did "not appropriately reflect what was said," without
elaborating.
"Perhaps there is someone who wants to try to retreat from what we agreed
upon," Melchior said.
Efraim Zadoff, an historian who has researched the plight of Jews who were
among the "disappeared," suggested that Argentinean authorities feared
the
implication of people still in positions of influence.
"I fear that he (the Argentine president) is backing off because ... some
of
the murderers are still among the government, police, and army today,"
Zadoff said.
Jaimovich, today a 50-year-old economist living in central Israel, said
he
learned from former prison camp inmates that his sister's Jewishness led
her
captors to subject her to especially harsh treatment and increased torture.
"It is expected that the Israeli government represents Jews and should
deal
with such problems -- to check what role anti-Semitism played and why
Jews were treated worse," Jaimovich said.
Others who lost family members during the military years said it is not
necessarily Israel's role to track down the bodies.
Noga Tarnapolsky, an Israeli journalist who is writing a book on her own
family's experience under Argentina's military rule, said the victims were
targeted primarily because they were perceived as dissidents, although
Jews
were singled out for especially rough treatment.
"The Jews killed in Argentina are an Argentine problem," Tarnapolsky, who
lost five family members, said in a phone interview. "They were murdered
as
Argentinean citizens."
De la Rua's predecessor, Carlos Menem, pardoned the top junta leaders in
1990, just five years after they were jailed for life for human rights
abuses.
Raising the issue of the "disappeared" is still sensitive in Argentina.
For the families, the pain lingers. Jaimovich spoke of the toll of wrestling
with
the loss of "disappeared" for as long as 25 years.
"It breaks down families, people don't know how to function, it's paralyzing,"
he said, "With no body there is nothing to bury, this makes it much harder."